LIFESTYLE
This week, as a band consisting mostly of religious groups attempts to stop the repeal of Section 377, the government has been asked to supply data on how many homosexuals in the country have HIV.
This week, as a band consisting mostly of religious groups attempts to stop the repeal of Section 377, the government has been asked to supply data on how many homosexuals in the country have HIV. What is the connection between this disease and human rights, and is it valid, asks Apoorva Dutt
Jayesh Vas, 27, calls himself a “slacktivist homo”, shorthand for the fact that though he is an out-of-the-closet gay man (“Blurted it out at 21 and never looked back,” he says proudly) he has never followed the legalities and politics of being gay in India with particular enthusiasm.
“I was very happy though, about the repeal of Section 377,” he remembers. “Though I have never been harassed, a number of my friends had been.” The appeal was filed by an eclectic mix including religious groups, yoga guru Baba Ramdev and children’s rights groups. It is being heard by the Supreme Court, to make being gay a criminal act once again, he says, in a resigned tone, that he was expecting it. But what surprised him was the news item that caught his eye a couple of weeks ago. “The Supreme Court has asked the government to explain how many gays in the country have HIV,” says a disbelieving Vas. “I was so angry — what does a deadly disease have to do with basic human rights?”
This week, the health and family welfare ministry has informed the the Supreme Court that there are roughly 28,000-31,000 ‘men who have sex with men’, or MSM, in the country who are at ‘high risk’ for contracting HIV. But how was that data being compiled? “Well, no one came to my doorstep to ask if I’m gay or not, so I doubt they have an accurate number,” cackles Vas. “I don’t understand why this information is important.”
Aiding the fight
Unfortunately, it is. The question of LGBT rights in India has always been entangled with the question of HIV and its prevalence within the community, as Vikram Doctor, a gay rights activist working with Gay Bombay, points out. “A lot of people forget that HIV was the reason used in the very beginning to combat Section 377.” Doctor goes on to explain that when activists and lawyers began fighting this case over ten years ago, it didn’t look like the judiciary would be sympathetic to the repeal from the angle of “only human rights”. “The government wasn’t even willing to call us ‘gay’; the technical term used was ‘males who have sex with males’, or MSM. So we brought in the question of HIV. It is an undeniable fact that percentage-wise, MSM have a higher proportion of those who are HIV-infected.”
The petition, originally filed by a group called the Naz Foundation, said that Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code made it difficult for them to educate homosexuals on the risks of HIV/AIDS, and therefore, infringed upon the group’s constitutional right to health. This argument was supported by the health ministry, but opposed by the home ministry on the grounds of public morality. So, data on HIV might actually aid the fight to legalise homosexuality. “As you know, there is no known cure for AIDS,” says Aditya Bandopadhyay, a lawyer and gay rights activist. “The only way forward is prevention. This can only happen if an environment is created where there is access to knowledge. This, in turn, will only happen if homosexuality is decriminalised.”
Nagesh Agarwal, 45, is a gay man who has been living with HIV for the last ten years. Originally from Delhi, he relocated to Mumbai in order to head a theatre group. Since then, he has been actively involved in street theatre aimed at increasing HIV awareness, as well as promoting gay rights. “In my spare time, I also counsel HIV-positive people through a partnership with a gay rights NGO in the city,” says Agarwal.
“As a gay man who has come to a grave realisation of the risks of unsafe sex practices, as well as worked to prevent the same happening to others, I know that knowledge is the only way forward. 7.3% of MSM are likely to be infected with HIV, according to the latest affidavit. Criminalising a gay person’s very identity is not moral from either a health or a humane point of view.”
Gay rights has science on its side
The reason that asking for this data has made many uncomfortable is that groups tend to use the prevalence of HIV as being the responsibility of the gay community.
However, Bandopadhyay maintains that it is good that the data is being asked for. “Asking for the information is the right step. The fact that the gay population exists in huge numbers should be revealed.” He admits though, that any number they arrive at would at best be “an estimation”. “The scale used customarily estimatesthe homosexual population to be four to 10% of the population.”
“These are extremely dubious estimates,” says Karan Purohit, 35, a queer writer and academic. “When I can’t even tell my parents I’m gay, is the government really going to be the first to find out?”
According to a study released in 2010 by the government’s National Aids Control Organisation (NACO) - the most common cause of transmission of HIV is heterosexual sex, which accounts for 87.1% of infections, even if the LGBT community includes a higher percentage of HIV-plagued people than the straight population.
“If HIV-infection is playing a role in deciding gay rights, by that logic, heterosexual sex should be banned as well,” points out Purohit.
Senior counsel Fali Nariman, appearing on behalf of parents with gay children, pointed out that at the time of the writing of the Indian Penal Code, a Constitution was not in place, which should be taken under consideration now, under the right to health provision. Bandopadhyay believes that the anti-repeal group is trying to equate an entire community with a disease.
“Their side (those opposing the repeal) is the prejudiced side. What gives me hope is that gay rights have science on their side. Equating homosexuality with HIV is tantamount to blaming the rape victim for a rape.”
IND vs NZ, 2nd Test Dream11 prediction: Fantasy cricket tips for India vs New Zealand match
How To Prepare For The UPSC CSE 2025 Exam?
'India supports dialogue and diplomacy, not war': PM Modi at BRICS Summit
This woman lost in Dubai's desert orders camel via Uber, netizens say 'your camel has arrived'
Good news for Vijay Shekhar Sharma, Paytm gets NPCI nod to..., shares surge over 7%
Fan requests Rohit Sharma to deliver her message to Virat Kohli, here's how Indian captain responded
Rajkummar Rao recalls being scammed in Delhi during struggle days: 'The man had...'
Robbers pose as customers in jewellery shop, what owner did next will leave you shocked
Maharashtra Elections 2024: NCP releases 1st list of 38 candidates; Ajit Pawar to contest from…
Japanese Shah Rukh Khan leaves Bollywood Badshah's fan impressed, social media says...
Will KL Rahul be retained by LSG ahead of IPL Auction? New report provides BIG update, it says...
'Wayanad will have two MPs': Rahul Gandhi after Priyanka files nomination for bypolls
I Want To Talk teaser: Abhishek Bachchan announces his next with Shoojit Sircar, to release on...
Diwali 2024: When is Deepawali, October 31 or November 1? Check dates, mahurat timings and more
JEE Main 2025 exam date to release TODAY: Know how to register, check exam calendar HERE
Jhalmuri fever hits London: Video of British man selling Kolkata-style street food goes viral, watch
SC slams Centre as Delhi air worsens, calls environment laws...
Ex-cricketer suggests replacing KL Rahul with THIS batsman for 2nd Test vs NZ, he is…
TMC MP Kalyan Banerjee smashes bottle, hurls it towards Chair in row over Waqf meet
Know how Mukesh Ambani and Nita Ambani's children Isha Ambani and Akash Ambani got their names
Family finds venomous snakes under their bed, what happened next will leave you in shock
This company's Vice President gets fired after raise and bonus, reason will leave you shocked
Mukesh Ambani-led Jio Financial eyes JVs with Allianz SE in insurance sector
IMD's BIG update: Cyclone Dana forms over Bay of Bengal, to cross Odisha-Bengal coasts on...
This company gifts cars as Diwali bonus, calls its employees celebrities, is owned by…
Amid divorce rumours with Aishwarya Rai, Abhishek Bachchan skips her family gathering
When Ratan Tata opened up about his parents separation, first love and childhood, he said...
Blow to Mukesh Ambani ahead of Isha Ambani, Akash Ambani's birthday, Reliance stocks...
Saudi Arabia's futuristic megacity project Neom a big threat to migratory birds? Experts say...
Apple CEO Tim Cook didn’t know about this iPhone feature, left speechless, know here
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Jio offers superhit Diwali plan, unlimited 5G internet for just Rs...
Bengaluru Rains: Schools closed, WFH advisory for private companies as IMD issues yellow alert
Israel confirms killing of Hashem Safieddine, presumed successor of Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah
Big move by Anil Ambani, his company to invest Rs 10000 crore to set up India's largest...
Meet Indian genius, who was born in small town, today leads AI innovations of Google, she is...
Woman stays at luxury resort worth Rs 3 lakh for free, claims she used...
Delhi AQI update: Air quality worsens to 'very poor' level at 349, becomes 'severe' in these areas
PM Modi to hold bilateral talks with Xi Jinping at BRICS Summit today
Odisha, West Bengal brace for Cyclone Dana: How was it named and what it means?
POCSO case: Mumbai Police ask Ekta Kapoor, her mother to appear for questioning tomorrow
Watch: Can you identify all the actors in this clip from 1991?
Priyanka Gandhi to file nomination for Wayanad Lok Sabha bypoll today
Meet woman, whose father used to sell milk, cracked UPSC exam with AIR 62 to become...
Delhi: No water supply in Capital for 12 hours on Friday due to…; check list of affected areas
Salman Khan resumes shooting for Sikandar amid death threats from Lawrence Bishnoi
India, Pakistan extend Kartarpur Sahib corridor agreement for five years
DNA TV Show: What is BRICS currency? Is it possible to introduce it today?
IPL 2025: Three-time IPL champion set to join Gujarat Titans as batting coach - Reports
PM Modi, Xi Jinping to hold bilateral meet on sidelines of BRICS Summit on Oct 23, first in 5 years
New Himalayan snake species named after Academy Award winner Leonardo DiCaprio, it will be called…
Cyclone Dana: Schools closed in West Bengal, Odisha for 4 days from...
Delhi govt to provide special assistance of Rs 5000 monthly to...
Rape-accused Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein diagnosed with bone marrow cancer
IND vs NZ: Sarfaraz Khan or KL Rahul; Who will find a spot in 2nd Test? India coach says…
Mumbai Police interrogates Ekta Kapoor, her mother Shobha Kapoor in case under POCSO act
Mukesh Ambani may team up with govt to sell food products through...
Bengaluru: Several feared trapped as under-construction building collapses
Best Cheap VPS Hosting Providers: Top Picks for Hosting Under USD 10
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal set to raise Rs 8500 crore, says it is meant to...