INDIA
The Supreme Court on Tuesday observed that the probing agencies could not question the legitimacy of an adult's choice to marry a person of their choice.
The Supreme Court on Tuesday observed that the probing agencies could not question the legitimacy of an adult's choice to marry a person of their choice.
The top court had reconvened for the first time since it had allowed Hadiya, aka Akhila KM, a 24-year-old homeopathy students from Kerala to move out of her parents home and study in Salem, Tamil Nadu.
"She is a 24-year-old girl. If an adult says she married someone with her own consent, how can one contest that marriage?" the bench led by Chief Justice Dipak Misra said.
The bench, also comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar and DY Chandrachud, said an investigation by the National Investigation Agency (NIA) in the Kerala love jihad matter would not have a bearing on Hadiya's marital status.
However, representing Hadiya's father Ashokan KM — who had opposed his daughter's marriage to Shafin Jahan — advocate Madhavi Divan said, "Your Lordships are looking at marriage in isolation. Please note that she was not married at the time the petition was filed before the Kerala High Court. The prayer at that time was that the girl was unwilling to return to her parents. The marriage is merely a devise to legitimise her illegal confinement."
To this, Justice CHandrachud said, "You may be right that the marriage is solely a devise. But once Hadiya says that she is married, we cannot question the legitimacy of her choice. How can the writ of habeas corpus be issued in respect of an adult girl?"
However Divan argued that perhaps the marriage was not out of choice if she did not posses the mental capabilities to take the decision on her own. "In this one of a kind case, the court is required to examine the extent of the habeas corpus jurisdiction where an adult does not have any known physical or mental incapacity. Here marriage was a device to legitimise her confinement with the conversion institution. The court cannot shut it's eyes to a highly sophisticated network at play where marriage was only a last step in a much larger modus operandi," Divan argued.
Cutting Divan in the middle, CJI Misra said, "Marriage should be free of any criminal conspiracy, criminal affability or criminal action. Otherwise it shall be a bad precedent in law. 'X' married 'Y'- that is it. We cannot get into if the choice is independent."
"My prayer is not regarding the marriage. We are not only concerned about the welfare. When the girl is an adult, what is the jurisdiction of the High Court to grant the writ of habeas corpus if the girl is deemed to be mentally or intellectually insufficient?" Divan persisted.
"The girl has appeared before us as well as the High Court. She is not in illegal detention," CJI Misra said. "We cannot see how she has been brainwashed. We cannot interfere," the bench said towards the end of the matter.
After almost 11 months, Hadiya was allowed to live by herself and complete her studies, without parental supervision. In November 2017, the top court had granted her request for freedom and allowed Haidya to continue her studies in TN. IN 2016, almost two eyars after Hadiya converted to islam, she married Shafin Jahan. In May 2017, the Kerela High Court had annulled her marriage on an appeal filed by her retired military man father Ashokan KM.
Subhash Ghai makes big investment, buys plush 4BHK apartment in Mumbai for...
Metovalex App Review 2025: Legit Or Scam Trading AI? - Real User Facts!
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato rebranded Eternal: Everyone has the same question
Thief gifts Rs 3cr house to girlfriend, everyone shocked after...
Who is Meghnad S? YouTuber and journalist who contested Delhi assembly polls 2025 from...
Does Sanya Malhotra's 'Mrs' promote a no-marriage culture among women?
BIG blow to Sundar Pichai as Google loses Rs 17501260000000 due to…
Caring for Ageing Parents? Essential tips to manage health, finances, and well-being
Meet Gautam Adani’s daughter-in-law Paridhi Adani: Know about her assets, career, family, and more
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah wedding: Inside pics from Gautam Adani's son's wedding festivity
Why has Premanand Maharaj stopped his morning yatras at 2 am?
Sonu Sood BREAKS SILENCE on arrest warrant against him in fraud case: 'It is sad that celebs...'
Akshata Murty once confronted her father and Infosys co-founder Narayana Murthy: 'My real dad is...'
Meet Alexis Wilkins, Trump's FBI chief pick Kash Patel's 'mystery girlfriend,' her profession is...
Fire breaks out at Mahakumbh Nagar camp, officials say no casualties reported so far
Who is Mohini Mohan Datta, mystery man set to get Rs 500 crore through Ratan Tata's will?
Cristiano Ronaldo makes shocking statement, breaks Portugal's hearts: 'I never thought about...'
Ludhiana court issues arrest warrant against Sonu Sood in fraud case
Happy Rose Day 2025: Significance of different coloured roses on Day 1 of Valentine's week
Salman Khan REVEALS why he avoids eating beef and pork: 'Main maanta hu meri maa...'
Shah Rukh Khan-Saif Ali Khan vs Aryan Khan-Ibrahim Khan: Who should be in KHNH2!
Why Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu gifted Donald Trump golden pager? It is a reference to...
Mob in Bangladesh destroys ousted PM Sheikh Hasina's family home
ISRO's EOS-06 satellite captures Phytoplankton concentration on global scale
IND vs ENG: Will Virat Kohli play in 2nd ODI vs England? Shubman Gill provides huge injury update
Who is Kiran Chaudhury? PCS officer caught in bribe case, just 4 years after posting
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah's wedding today: Know venue, gifts for guests and more
Meet woman, who works in Rs 163000 crore company, daughter of Hyderabad’s richest man
This is world's greenest railway station, 170 years old, home to over 7,000 plants, it's in....
As Sky Force nears Rs 150 crore, Nimrat Kaur treats househelp, her kids with movie screening
IND vs ENG: Shreyas Iyer creates history, becomes first player to achieve THIS massive milestone
Meet man, India's richest banker, who has bought Rs 202 crore property, his net worth is Rs...
'Heard there was....': Former India head coach provides major update on Virat Kohli's injury
A New Geopolitical Era: India and Israel's Role in the Evolving Middle East
David Warner’s touching moment with fans after Dubai Capitals reaches final of DP World ILT20
India’s Largest Book Stall Network: PrashantAdvait Foundation’s Mission to Revive Reading Culture
Mawra Hocane stuns in pastel mint green lehenga at her wedding to Ameer Gilani
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato changes its name, CEO shares journey of company, it is now called...
Rose Day 2025: Know the date, history, significance of each rose colour ahead of Valentine's day
'BJP-led NDA works for Santushtikaran, not Tushtikaran': PM Modi in Rajya Sabha
Who is Belle Gibson? Australian wellness guru created fake cancer story and later...
DP World ILT20 2025: Dubai Capitals clinch last ball thriller against Desert Vipers to reach final
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah wedding: First pic from Gautam Adani's mansion OUT as wedding festivities begin
Sunita Williams’ Spacewalk: A Record-Breaking Mission and a Stunning Selfie from Space
IND vs ENG: Ravindra Jadeja creates history in Nagpur, surpasses James Anderson to become....
Can IAS officers change cadres after marriage? Here's what rules say
Pavan Kumar Joshi innovates unemployment benefits payment security
Anil Ambani's company's share price surges over 6 per cent after it earns profit of Rs...