Business
It is officially estimated that the total stock of gold held by Indians will be in the region of 20,000 tonne. However the actual holding after taking into account unaccounted imports, ancestral holdings etc should actually be in the region of 25,000 to 30,000 tonne. The value of this gold at current prices will be $800 billion (roughly Rs 5,00,000 crore) for the official estimation and anywhere between $1-1.25 trillion (roughly Rs 6,50,000 crore) for the actual holding of gold.
Updated : Mar 20, 2018, 02:44 AM IST
For centuries, buying gold has been a tradition in India.
Over the last 10-15 years there has also been a huge increase in buying of gold in the form of coins and bars. This has happened mainly for two reasons. First, gold is being accumulated for future use as parents use their current cash flows to accumulate gold for their children’s marriages. Second, gold as a lucrative investment option as a result of the secular uptrend in the value of gold over the last decade. Gold has shown low volatility (at least in rupee terms) and has been used as a hedge against inflation.
The fact that gold prices in rupee terms are just about 10%-15% lower than their peak values in the domestic market due to the depreciation of the rupee as well as the increase in import duties has reinforced the belief of Indians in gold.
It is officially estimated that the total stock of gold held by Indians will be in the region of 20,000 tonne. However the actual holding after taking into account unaccounted imports, ancestral holdings etc should actually be in the region of 25,000 to 30,000 tonne. The value of this gold at current prices will be $800 billion (roughly Rs 5,00,000 crore) for the official estimation and anywhere between $1-1.25 trillion (roughly Rs 6,50,000 crore) for the actual holding of gold.
Now, the idea of gold monetisation has been in the thought process of policy makers for years now. However, no workable idea has come up till now. In the current year's Union Budget there was an announcement on the Gold Monetisation scheme which has undergone some changes since initially proposed.
This entire scheme is likely to be a big flop.
This is why:
In order to get gold out of peoples households and vaults it needs a huge incentive which the current proposal fails to address.
The issues which will lead this scheme to fail are as follows.
The government might be successful in getting some temple trusts to put in their gold into this scheme but that will be a very small proportion of the entire gold in the country. I do not see the monetization efforts getting even 100-200 tonne under the current scheme of things -- less than 10% of the total gold holding with Indians.
What is the solution?
The only way to get bigger quantities of gold to come into this scheme is to offer a 'gold amnesty scheme'.
I believe that the best way to run this scheme will be as follows:
Any of these options will boost the foreign exchange reserves, stabilize the rupee and build foreign exchange reserves. Now, the question is how much gold will the government need to get to make a meaningful impact?
At current prices one tonne of gold will be approximately $40 million. 25 tonnes will be required for $1 billion (Rs 6,400 crore). The government needs to target a quantity of 1000 tonne for an amount of $40 billion. This is 4-5% of the current holding of gold in India and should be easily possible.
This scheme will kill three birds with one stone. Unproductive gold in the hands of Indian’s will be converted into a productive financial asset, the government will be able to raise cheap long term money and the foreign exchange reserves will get a strong leg up. Given that the government will be able to realize around Rs 2, 50,000 crore in 10 year money it will also remove crowding out from the economy.
Dear Finance Minister, ponder.