UPA scores big win in confidence vote

NEW DELHI: The UPA Government on Tuesday scored an emphatic victory in the confidence vote in the Lok Sabha with a comfortable margin, ending the political uncertainty that will enable the ruling coalition to push ahead with the Indo-US civilian nuclear deal.
    
The motion, which was forced by the Left parties' decision to withdraw support to the Government on the deal, was adopted with sizeable cross-voting from Opposition members including at least one visibly from Telegu Desum.
   
There was erosion in opposition numbers with only 256 opposing the motion against 275 supporting it.
    
In a House with an effective strength of 541, the Government needed 271 and in the ultimate result it got four more than the half-way mark, belying predictions of a cliffhanger of a contest.
    
The day was marred by high drama when BJP members shocked the House displaying bundles of currency notes claiming Rs one crore was given to them as advance by a Samajwadi Party leader to abstain from voting.
    
Charges and counter-charges over the bribery allegations disrupted proceedings for over two hours with the Opposition members not allowing Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to make his customary reply winding up the two-day debate that was often
acrimonious.
    
In his six-page reply, which was laid on the table, the Prime Minister hit out at the Left parties saying "they wanted me to behave as their bonded slave."
    
"They wanted a veto over every single step of negotiations which is not acceptable," he said with regard to the negotiating processes he wanted to undertake with the International Atomic Energy Agency and the Nuclear Suppliers Group before operationalising the nuclear agreement.
    
Singh said the nuclear agreement will end India's nuclear isolation and apatheid and asserted that the agreements negotiated with the US, Russia, France and other countries would enable India to enter into international trade for civilian use without any interference with the nation's strategic nuclear programme. 

The Prime Minister said "I have often said that I am a politician by accident....... whatever I have done in this high office I have done so with a clear conscience and the best interest of my country."
    
M Jagannath of the TDP, who apparently defied the party whip, came to the Prime Minister soon after the vote and congratulated him. Later, he was seen seated in the Congress benches before the result was officially announced by the Speaker.
    
It was not also clear after the corrections how many abstained and how many votes were cast in all.
    
Leader of the Lok Sabha Pranab Mukherjee was the first to congratulate the Prime Minister followed by Congress President Sonia Gandhi who is also the UPA Chairperson.
    
The Prime Minister hugged Rahul Gandhi who made a brief speech hailing the Prime Minister's initiative on the nuclear deal.  Singh was also profusely congratulated by almost all the Union Ministers and members of the ruling combine who crowded around him while waiting for the official declaration of the result.
    
As Sonia Gandhi beamed in relief, Pranab Mukherjee was also the centre of attraction for the UPA MPs.
    
CPI-M member Varkala Radhakrishnan was the lone opposition MP to move to the treasury benches to congratulate the Prime Minister.

Leader of the Opposition L K Advani said it is a numerical victory, but there is something like moral legitimacy which is lacking. He admitted that 10 opposition MPs cross-voted.
     
Facing the trust vote after completion of four years in office, Manmohan Singh created history by winning the confidence vote as he is the first Prime Minister of Congress heading a coalition.
     
This was the second confidence motion moved by a Prime Minister in nine years but the contrast was stark with the earlier one tabled by Atal Bihari Vajpayee in April 1999 which he lost by just one vote.
     
This was also the first time that on a foreign policy and security issue the House was called upon to vote.
     
During the debate on the second day, Finance Minister P Chidambaram tore into the NDA and the Left parties, saying there can be "nothing more bizarre" than two disparate groups coming together to vote against the confidence motion.
      
Rahul Gandhi too made a strong pitch for the deal saying "fear of the unknown" should not deter a big country like India to go ahead with the initiative.
       
The debate was marred by the ruckus created by Opposition BSP and Left over the issue of alleged misuse of CBI against BSP Chief Mayawati to "force" her to support the UPA government.