ANALYSIS
Take heed of dissenting SC justices
The genesis of the unprecedented act of rebellion by four senior Supreme Court justices against Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra on Friday can be traced to the growing faultlines within the topmost echelon of the judiciary.
The battle of egos in November between Justice J Chelameswar and the CJI had turned into an unedifying public spectacle. The difference of opinions became such festering sores that they ended up compromising the health and credibility of the highest constitutional court of the country.
The dissenting voices of Justices Chelameswar, Ranjan Gogoi, Madan Lokur and Kurian Joseph have strengthened the belief that the biggest threat to the judiciary comes from within, one that is nurtured by conflicting interests and power struggles.
It’s more than just a worrying sign for the apex court because a turmoil of this nature has far-reaching consequences that have a direct bearing on the future of Indian democracy. If the judiciary flounders in this manner, that too in full public view, it bears evidence of the fact that the rot afflicting the SC has the potential to erode the very foundations of this country, where the system of checks and balances, provided by the Constitution, has suddenly become vulnerable.
By bringing matters – that traditionally have been sorted behind closed doors – to the court of public opinion, the four justices, who were later supported by two more colleagues, have intensified the call for a greater transparency in the administrative functions of the SC.
The CJI, as the justices pointed out, “is only the first among equals – nothing more or nothing less” who has certain “well-settled and time-honoured conventions” to assist him in drawing up of benches and assigning cases. The manner in which Justice Misra apparently carried out this responsibility had sown the seeds of discord.
Even when the aggrieved justices tried to resolve the issue through discussion, it didn’t yield the desired outcome. Though the Friday upheaval had a stunning effect, it seemed to be the only recourse for the four legal luminaries since knocking on government’s doors would have attracted the criticism of compromising the autonomy of the judiciary.
If the CJI is overlooking his seniormost colleagues in assigning cases, it can be interpreted as favouritism or worse still, an attempt to influence the outcome of justice. What is evident now is that Justice Misra has failed to evolve a consensus with other justices regarding the administrative functions of the apex court.
It’s true that Friday’s press conference has dented the judiciary’s image among the citizens – judges in this country are awe-inspiring figures, held in highest esteem – but by expressing their anguish in public, the four justices have taken a moral stand that will, in due course, restore people’s faith in the justice system.
The CJI Dipak Misra can’t afford to remain silent; he has to effectively rebut the general impression that he is taking the institution down with him. While the government’s decision not to interfere in the “internal” matter of the judiciary is praiseworthy, it will have to push the judges to end the stalemate.
It is now up to the judiciary to bring an end to this internecine feud and restore order and equanimity in the citadel of justice. The show of defiance on Tuesday should not go down in history as a bad precedent. Instead, it should stimulate the institution to embrace reforms.
DNA TV Show: Conflicting data on Delhi station stampede reveals communication gap
WATCH: Baba Ramdev at 59 takes part in race with horse, netizens say 'Olympics me chalo'
Delhi woman turns auto driver to support daughter, her story goes viral
Viral video declares Rajat Patidar ‘Captain of Captains’ after RCB names him Skipper, here's why
Indian Army havildar loses teen son, saves others’ lives by...
WPL 2025: Smriti Mandhana creates history during RCB vs DC match, becomes first player to cross...
Ronit Roy says he was the first choice for Pardes but he was replaced by...because...
‘Papa killed mummy': 4-year-old's drawing creates suspicion over woman’s alleged suicide
Sunil Mittal gets Rs 8486 crore after selling....; still seeks funds for newer...
How a low cost floor cleaning robot revolutinising home automation – Check details
Harvard Alum Aayush Puri: Move back to India, the future is here
Vicky Kaushal reveals how his fight scene with lion in Chhaava was shot: 'We were all so...'
Shabana Azmi holds her ears, issues public apology to Dabba Cartel co-star Jyotika; here's why
Meet Arvind Kejriwal’s daughter, who cracked IIT-JEE Advanced, went to IIT Delhi, now working as...
'Kohli never said a word': Pakistan's Haris Rauf on Virat Kohli hitting sixes against him in...
Bengaluru to witness hottest summer says IMD, recorded season’s highest temperature at...
Ranveer Singh to venture in production amid box office slump? Here's the truth
Where to Buy Testosterone in the USA? Top 3 Best Brands of Testosterone Cypionate in 2025
Pregnant woman employee gets Rs 1 crore compensation after being fired through...
ELECRAMA 2025: Powering the Future of Energy
Steroids for Sale in the USA: Buy Steroids Online in 2025
How to Choose Trenbolone for Sale Online? Review of Popular Trenbolone Manufacturers
After disrupting Indian market, Mukesh Ambani takes THIS popular brand to...
Remedium Lifecare Lands Rs 182 Crore Multi-Year Contract: Stock Set for Major Upturn
Former ISRO chief AS Kiran Kumar visits Goenka Temple, expresses hope for successful Mars mission
Anil Ambani's Rs 9831 crore company set to enter NEW space, makes key...
347 rooms, Rs 22400 crore worth: India's most expensive wedding venue is located in...
Vladimir Putin's BIG warning to Ukraine, will negotiate only if...
Woman constable carries baby on duty, RPSF says, 'she serves, she...', video goes viral
'Caught Red-Handed': Cognizant accuses Narayana Murthy's Infosys of stealing THIS secret in...
'Bharat Jodo Vivah': Wedding invite of Jammu's daughter, Kerala's son wows internet
Pavitra Rishta fame Usha Nadkarni cries inconsolably as she remembers her brother's death, watch
MASSIVE discount on Apple iPhone 16, iPhone 15, check here how to grab this deal
Juhi Chawla takes holy dip at Mahakumbh 2025, calls it 'most beautiful morning in her life'
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato launches first AI product ‘Nugget,’ says will give it for free to…
Champions Trophy 2025: 5 major records that Virat Kohli can break in this tournament
Shweta Basu Prasad says she was bullied on Telugu film set: 'I was called...'
Gujarat: Lion brings traffic to a halt at Bhavnagar-Somnath highway, watch viral video
India's Got Latent row: SC grants interim relief from arrest to Ranveer Allahbadia
Tesla begins hiring in India after PM Modi-Musk meet, announces multiple job roles in...
Gurugram woman shares interview experience at Zomato, CEO Deepinder Goyal reacts, says...
'Sir ek kiss ho jaye': Paps unleash a horror welcome on Udit Narayan
Salman Khan, Sanjay Dutt REUNITE for Hollywood thriller, filming begins in Saudi Arabia: Report
Gujarat: Videos of women patients leaked on Telegram, YouTube, probe ordered
South Korean actress Kim Sae-ron found dead at home, cause of death revealed
Canada: Delta Airlines plane crashes at Toronto Pearson airport, flips upside down, several injured
Meet Gyanesh Kumar, IIT graduate, who becomes new Chief Election Commissioner
DNA TV Show: RSS' Bihar model ahead of Assembly elections in state
WPL 2025: Renuka, Wareham spark collapse as RCB bowl out Delhi Capitals for 141