ANALYSIS
Congress’s battery of lawyers wants to put a brake on Supreme Court’s hearing of the case
During waves of Islamic invasions of India over the centuries, thousands of temples were demolished. It is therefore incomprehensible why Muslims in India should oppose rebuilding temples. It would not be atonement for ancestral sins; it would simply be an honourable act.
But why insist on building a Ram temple at the site in Ayodhya where the Babri structure stood? There are two reasons. First, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) has proved conclusively that a temple once lay beneath the Babri rubble. Second, the birthplace of Ram holds special significance for Hindus. If Muslims are to help build a temple, what better place to build it than where devout Hindus believe Lord Ram was born?
The dispute over building the Ram temple in Ayodhya, currently being heard in the Supreme Court, terrifies some politicians. Arguing for delaying the apex court’s verdict to after the 2019 Lok Sabha election, senior advocate and Rajya Sabha Congress MP Kapil Sibal pleaded with the Supreme Court with folded hands for a long adjournment. The court dismissed his plea. It will continue to hear the case though not on a day-to-day basis. The next hearing is scheduled for March 14.
Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra has made it clear though that the case will be heard as a land-title dispute. Matters of faith will not be adjudicated. Who does the land title of the disputed site belong to? The Shia Wakf Board controversially claimed deed to the title. The claim was rejected by the Allahabad High Court in 2010. The court decreed that the disputed 2.77-acre site should be divided into three equal parts between the Sunni Central Wakf Board of Uttar Pradesh, the Nirmohi Akhara sect and Ramlalla Virajman. It is this verdict, arrived at by a 2-1 majority, that the Supreme Court will adjudicate.
The Shia Wakf Board supports building the Ram temple at the disputed site in Ayodhya. It says it will help construct a grand new mosque at a suitable site elsewhere, possibly in Lucknow. The Sunni Wakf Board is leading the Opposition to building the Ram temple at the disputed site. Several political parties with an interest in the Muslim vote bank have joined the Sunni Board in its strenuous opposition. They reject the ASI’s findings that a temple ever once stood there.
The Ram temple issue is an inflammable mix of history, religion and politics. With the Lok Sabha election due in April 2019 and possibly earlier, politics has taken centre stage. The BJP knows that Uttar Pradesh is vital to its chances of winning a second term. It calculates that keeping the Ram temple issue alive will help it cushion the impact of a possible, if unlikely, alliance between the BSP and SP-Congress in UP. Such an alliance could make it difficult for the BJP to capture the 60-plus seats it needs in UP to form a stable BJP-led NDA coalition government in 2019.
There are now three possibilities. One, the Supreme Court finds in favour of the Allahabad High Court’s judgement. That will hand two-thirds of the 2.77-acre disputed site to two Hindu organisations (the Nirmohi Akhara sect and Ramlalla Virajman). All parties in the dispute have agreed to abide by the Supreme Court’s ruling. If the apex court accepts the Allahabad High Court’s formula, the two Hindu groups will get two-thirds of the 2.77-acre site. The hardline Sunni Wakf Board will get the rest. This outcome will suit the BJP. It can showcase it as a victory for devout Hindus and energise its core voter base.
The second possibility is that the Supreme Court rejects the Allahabad High Court’s verdict on dividing the land into three equal parts. That will throw the matter back into the hands of the litigants for out-of-court negotiations that have sputtered on and off over the past few months. This will keep the issue alive and again help the BJP electorally.
That leads to the third possibility. If the Supreme Court delays its verdict beyond 2019, as Sibal has pleaded, the BJP’s more radical elements will attempt to force the issue by unilaterally preparing to lay the foundation of the Ram temple. They will transport bricks and other material to the site. The Yogi Adityanath government will not allow the devotees to do any actual construction. But the symbolism of a “saffron army” marching to honour Lord Ram in Ayodhya will pay the BJP electoral dividends.
The Ram temple controversy has also laid bare the schism within the Muslim clergy. The Shia Wakf Board vocally supports building the Ram temple at the disputed site. It has been in close touch with Sri Sri Ravi Shankar to seek an out-of-court settlement. It has sought a ban on the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) which, along with the Sunni Wakf Board, strongly opposes building the temple at the disputed site in Ayodhya. The Congress’ battery of senior lawyers is meanwhile keen to put a brake on the Supreme Court hearing the case. It is keenly aware that, whichever way the gavel falls, Lord Ram spells electoral danger for the Congress.
The writer is author of The New Clash of Civilizations: How The Contest Between America, China, India and Islam Will Shape Our Century. Views expressed are personal.
Delhi Pollution: National capital's PM 2.5 Levels 13% higher than previous Diwali, reports suggest
J-K: Five injured after terrorists attack Srinagar weekly market with grenades
Mukesh Ambani's Reliance earns Rs 15393 crore during festive season, market cap reaches Rs...
This city that gives maximum number of IAS officers, its not Mumbai, Kolkata, the UPSC hub is...
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra's emotional message for people of Wayanad: 'When my brother was facing...'
Margot Robbie welcomes baby boy with husband Tom Ackerley
How can India qualify for WTC final after humiliating whitewash against New Zealand
Deepika Padukone-Ranveer Singh's baby girl has Sania Mirza connect, Bollywood couple reveals....
Bigg Boss 18: THIS actor replaces Salman Khan, to host reality show for...
WTC 2023-25 points table update after New Zealand's historic Test series win over India
IND vs NZ test: India lose against New Zealand by 25 runs, lost test series at home after…
'Vibe hai': Indonesian siblings 'Dilbar' rendition leaves Big Boss fame amazed
IND vs NZ test: Recap of BGT? Rishabh Pant last hope as India close to whitewash at home after...
Rajpal Yadav loses his cool, snatches journalist's phone, SHOCKING video goes viral
Warch: Land Rover bitten by Hippo, tourists witness intense faceoff as..., video goes viral
Fake IPS officer's epic dance to Bhojpuri song takes internet by storm, watch viral video
WI vs ENG: Shai Hope goes past Babar Azam, Virat Kohli in elite list with 17th ODI century
'If he doesn't resign...': Mumbai police receives threat call for UP CM Yogi Adityanath
IPL 2025: KKR CEO reveals reason that led to Shreyas Iyer's exit from franchise
HM Amit Shah releases BJP's 'Sankalp Patra' for Jharkhand assembly polls
Aishwarya Rai Bachchan recalls when she was announced Miss World 1994: 'We had rehearsals for...'
Drunk UP man call police over 250 grams missing potatoes, demands...,WATCH
Kartik Aaryan says somebody scratched him on the sets of Bhool Bhulaiyaa 3, he asks ‘if it was…’
Kiran Rao says Aamir Khan knows 'nothing' about son Azad's school: 'When we were married, I was...'
Trouble for Anil Ambani: SEBI issues demand notice of Rs 1540000000 over...
Nvidia to replace rival Intel in Dow Jones indices by November 8
Isha Ambani Vs Eiesha Bharti Pasricha: Know their net worth, college, academic qualifications
Salman Khan remembers designer Rohit Bal, says...
Bigg Boss 18: Salman Khan's Weekend Ka Vaar timing changed, details inside
Bhai Dooj 2024: Date, shubh muhurat, timings, rituals, significance
Delhi AQI touches 400: Many times over WHO limit, pollution in 'severe' category
Aishwarya Rai Bachchan says she rejected Shah Rukh Khan's film because Abhishek Bachchan wasn't...
Four children among six injured in attack on Gaza vaccination centre
IIT students launch dustbin in air using firecracker, WATCH viral video
Happy Bhai Dooj 2024: Top 50 wishes, What'sApp messages, quotes to share with your loved ones
IND vs NZ: Shubman Gill surpasses Cheteshwar Pujara in elite WTC list led by Rohit Sharma
DNA TV Show: Hindus in Bangladesh unite against fundamentalism
‘Another example of…’: MEA on Canada labelling India ‘cyber adversary’
'Bhai kyu jhooti tassali....': Mrunal Thakur criticizes fan who photoshopped her in Diwali pic
Mukesh Ambani, Anil Ambani set to earn money from Singham Again's box office collection, here’s how
Adani Power cuts Bangladesh electricity supply by half due to $846 million unpaid bills
Here's what is happening inside Ratan Tata’s Bombay House since after death of business magnate
Virat Kohli dispels retirement rumours, suggests he may continue playing cricket till....
Meet man, highest UPSC exam scorer, who broke IAS Tina Dabi's record, he is...
Swati Maliwal pours bottle of polluted water outside Delhi CM Atishi’s residence; WATCH
IPL 2025: R Ashwin tops CSK's wishlist as franchise plans to utilize RTM for THIS New Zealand star
'Abki baar...': AI imagines Donald Trump, Kamala Harris as Indian politicians, netizens react, WATCH
Amid bomb threats, ammunition cartridges found in Dubai-Delhi Air India flight
This Indian king, was first man to make history by marrying foreign woman during his trip to...
Mukesh Ambani's Jio once again TOPPED in global telecom industry, sets record in...
Bhai Dooj 2024: Date, shubh muhurat, significance, rituals and more
New ‘Satoshi Nakamoto’ emerges: Meet man who declares himself to be Bitcoin founder but fails to...
Watch: Former CSK star gets hit for 6 sixes in an over against England during Hong Kong Sixes
'Makes no sense': Ex-India star slams Rohit Sharma, Gautam Gambhir for absurd Sarfaraz Khan decision
World's richest man Elon Musk faces lawsuit from Ex-Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal for...
Security forces kill 2 terrorists, including a foreign national in Jammu and Kashmir
WWE Crown Jewel 2024: Full match card, timing, live streaming details - All you need to know
'Absurd and baseless': India dismisses Canadian minister's allegations against Amit Shah
IND vs NZ: Virat Kohli scripts history in Mumbai Test, becomes first player in world to...
This 51-year-old woman leaves husband to marry 30-year-old Indian security guard