LIFESTYLE
Why have some nations prospered and created positive living conditions for their citizens, while others have failed? The book discusses three central points to answer this question
Why Nations Fail
Daron Acemoglu & James A Robinson
Hachette India
529 pages
Rs599
It’s a situation right out of an eighties Bollywood potboiler. Two brothers are separated in wartime. One avoids being drafted into the army, and stays back in his country. The other, an army doctor, is taken north by the invading hordes. They meet 50 years later and marvel at the different paths their lives have taken.
But in Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity And Poverty, the brothers are Korean, and their divergent lives are used to support the book’s central thesis — that political and economic institutions determine the success or failure of a country. The brother in South Korea has a car, a telephone, wads of cash and a warm coat. But the North Korean brother has no car, no money, a threadbare coat and can only use the phone at the Foreign Ministry.
Why have some nations prospered and created positive living conditions for their citizens, while others have failed? Why Nations Fail discusses three central points to answer this question. First, ‘inclusive institutions’ where power is broadly distributed are necessary for economic growth. Second, political institutions are the guiding force for economic institutions, and therefore trump them in importance. Third, a majority of nations “get it wrong”, and this is the unfortunate norm.
One of the core reasons behind getting it wrong traced by the book is the “fear of creative destruction” by a section of the population — that the disruptive force of new technologies or a more even distribution of power will harm their self-interest. The book posits that only when inspired leadership meets conditions that allow for inclusive institutions to be in everyone’s — including the elite’s — interests, will prosperity ensue.
The style is simple, and the anecdotes engaging. For example, in 16th century Kongo, an African kingdom, “taxes were arbitrary; one was collected every time the king’s beret fell off”. The contrasts drawn, such as the one between the two Korean brothers, are used convincingly — Nogales as a town in both Mexico and USA and Bill Gates versus another billionaire Carlos Slim are a couple. But the book’s best argument, whether the authors realise it or not, is in the physics-like approach to historical change.
Changes such as the Black Death’s spread across Western Europe which wiped out half the labour force and hence forever changed their economies, are drawn deftly. But the problem with such a hypothesis is that it is entirely retrospective. Is there any way to predict, using the book’s logic (as it does in explaining why the Industrial Revolution happened in Britain and not in Spain) when the next ‘critical juncture’ for a nation will be? No.
North America is the shining example of a nation with inclusive institutions in the book, and other nations are successful based on how closely their institutions mirror the US’s model of private ownership, personal autonomy and Constitution. The China question is never far, and when it is finally dealt with, is unconvincing. China’s economic growth is mirage-like, according to the authors, and its political institutions “will not bring sustained growth and will run out of steam”. This blanket statement is not fortified with any critical argument.
The book is intended for a general audience and delivers in that regard. It is simply written, and concepts are painstakingly explained with no assumption of previous knowledge of economics or history. Overall, it’s a well-reasoned defence of the long-term successes of democratic and inclusive institutions.
Madhya Pradesh: Four naxalites, including three women, gunned down in Balaghat encounter
Who was Melissa Hortman? US lawmaker, her husband shot dead inside their home in Minnesota
Watch: Keshav Maharaj cries, Temba Bavuma covers his face after South Africa win WTC Final at Lord's
'I am differently abled': Delhi man’s ice cream order turns into a lesson in kindness
Anirudh Ravichander breaks silence on his marriage rumours with Kavya Maran, asks fans to...
WTC 2025 Final Prize Money: Australia walk away with Rs 186300000, winners South Africa get....
Pizza from a vending machine? Japan’s latest food innovation goes viral
Will Israel-Iran conflict affect oil prices in India? Fuel rates to…
'You are so weak': HR sparks backlash after insulting woman seeking leave for fever
Anderson-Tendulkar trophy launch postponed ahead of India-England Test series due to THIS reason
Ahead of India-England Test series, BCCI requests ECB to rethink over renaming....
Israel-Iran War: Israel defence minister's BIG warning to Iran, says 'Tehran will burn if...'
Karan Veer Mehra pens emotional note on Sushant Singh Rajput's death anniversary: 'You pushed me…'
PM Modi to attend G7 Summit in Canada, travel to Cyprus, meet leaders in Croatia from...
Meet Krishang Joshi, NEET UG 2025 topper with AIR 3, got 99.9999095 percentile, he is from...
Meet Utkarsh Awadhiya, NEET UG 2025 topper with AIR 2, his percentile is..., he is from...
Meet Mahesh Kumar, NEET UG 2025 topper with 99.9999547 percentile, secured AIR 1, he is from...
'Meri ek kiss ne...': Dharmendra talks about his kissing scene with Shabana Azmi, calls it…
NEET UG Result 2025 DECLARED at neet.nta.nic.in; direct link, list of toppers here
After multiple delays, Indian astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla's Axiom-4 mission to launch on...
'Bunny Hop' catches to become illegal soon? Check what new MCC law says about boundary catch
Karisma Kapoor's ex-husband Sunjay Kapur's funeral in Delhi might face delay due to...
Mukesh Ambani and Nita Ambani's son Anant Ambani takes big decision, decides to donate..., meets...
AUS vs SA: Will rain stand between South Africa and WTC 2025 title on Day 4?
This Chennai based startup gifts employees increment, brand new SUVs due to..., its business is....
Weather update: Delhi-NCR sizzles under intense heatwave, IMD predicts rain, thunderstorm on...
Google CEO Sundar Pichai Vs Apple CEO Tim Cook: Who gets highest salary? The answer is...
Viral video: Foreign woman names her daughter 'India', due to this REASON, Internet reacts, watch
'Didi sharma gayi': RJ Mahvash blushes as paps tease her about Yuzvendra Chahal, fans react, watch
Raj Kundra says 'I can't lie to save my...' after he exits The Traitors: ‘My wife is...'
Mohammad Rizwan, Babar Azam, Shaheen Afridi's T20I careers over? Ignored for Pakistan's tours of...
World’s Largest Banks 2025: THIS bank retains no. 1 spot for third year in row, check top rankings
Brother recalls last words to sister before Air India crash: 'Gave her a hug, asked to take care'
What caused Ahmedabad plane crash? Experts weigh in on possible reasons behind Air India tragedy
Why did Google start Doodles? 7 lesser-known facts about Google Doodles we bet you didn't know