MUMBAI
Prisoner was accused of firing at jail official in 1988.
The Bombay high court recently acquitted a man who was accused of trying to kill a jailor at Thane Central prison 25 years ago.
Disbelieving the jailor’s testimony, the court held that the police cooked up a story and arrested the suspect wrongly for the crime in 1988 as the jailor had allegedly chastised the accused for getting into a brawl with other inmates while being lodged in the jail.
Justice RC Chavan, while acquitting Mulund resident Prabhakar Mane, said, “Jailor Bhagwan Jagtap himself said that three shots were fired at him [Jagtap] with an interval of one second between two shots, which made him flee inside his house. It’s doubtful that he would’ve had enough opportunity to see the miscreants.”
“Jagtap also said that he told about the incident only to another jailor Abhiman Randive.
The latter categorically stating that Jagtap had told him he had been fired at by some unknown miscreants shows that the name of the appellant (Mane) and the other miscreants surfaced after inferences,” Justice Chavan added.
As per the prosecution’s case, on December 12, 1988, when Jagtap was sitting in his official quarters, three assailants fired at him, injuring his hands. It was alleged that three months prior to the firing there had been a commotion inside the prison and he had reprimanded the three accused who, after being released, fired at him.
The police charged the three under section 307 (attempt to murder) of the India Penal Code and some sections of the Arms Act. The trial court in 1989 acquitted two accused but convicted Mane and sentenced him to seven years’ imprisonment. He then challenged the conviction in high court.
The defence argued that it would have been technically impossible for the victim to see the assailants in such a short period of the incident. Also, after committing the alleged crime, the assailants wouldn’t have waited but tried to flee from the spot, thus reducing the chances of the victim seeing them, the defence added.
It was also argued that the victim had only reported about the incident to another jailor, but the FIR lodged by Randive was prepared by jail superintendent Mehsaram and the complicity of the appellant and the other accused in the assault was possibly a figment of his imagination. The defence added that the attempt to provide a motive to the assault shows that jail authorities were trying to cook something up.
The HC set aside the trial court’s conviction order after going through the entire evidence and taking note of the fact that most witnesses in the case had turned hostile and that there were other contradictions in the prosecution’s story.
Shots of revenge
On December 12, 1988, jailor Bhagwan Jagtap was at his official quarters when three assailants fired at him, injuring his hands.
It was alleged that three months before the incident, the jailor had reprimanded the accused for creating a commotion inside the prison. The jailor alleged that these persons had fired at him to exact revenge.
Donald Trump issues BIG warning to Hamas, says 'all hell will break out' if...
Anil Ambani's RCap buy: Hinduja Group firm set to acquire debt-ridden Reliance Capital by THIS date
Meet man, MBA graduate from Harvard, who leads one of world’s big tech firms as CEO, he is...
Delhi-Dehradun Expressway opens, check travel time, toll fee and more
What happens during Snow Moon and when does it appear? Check dates and when to see
‘RBI’s gold buying is...’: FM Nirmala Sitharaman talks about rising gold reserves by central bank
Meet the Muslim king all set to challenge Donald Trump over Gaza, he is from...
Ranveer Allahbadia’s viral joke on Samay Raina's India's Got Latent was stolen! The original was...
THIS Indian billionaire carries coffin of his employee, netizens call him ‘true leader’
Days after Jeet Adani-Diva Shah's marriage, Gautam Adani set to spend Rs 6000 crore on...
'Please let me stay the night:' Female trainee asked to leave Infosys premises at 6 pm even after...
Auto driver’s son studies at IIT, but luxury hotel refuses his auto's entry, billionaire calls it...
Who is Kuldeep Sharma? Ex-IPS gets three-month jail term in...
Meet woman, who lived in village, later got job at Amazon, now working in US as...
Beef Biryani Row Explained: Police file FIR day after incident at AMU; here's what happened
Meet Anant Ahuja, Sonam Kapoor's brother-in-law who reportedly got Rs 6.56 cr by USAID
BIG move by Mukesh Ambani, launches Rs 10 product with former cricket star, it is...
Car gets stuck in wheat field in the dead of night, know what Google Maps error caused later
The Chabahar Puzzle: India’s Connectivity Dreams in US-Iran Turmoil
Delhi: Girls showcase their skills, strength in netball, Aali and Lal Kuan emerge winners
Elon Musk reacts to UK MP’s demand to replace 'Bengali' signboard at London Station, check here
Anupam Mittal's unique gift to Gautam Adani's son Jeet Adani will leave you in splits
Man dies after being sexually assaulted in Delhi, one arrested, this is what happened
After Deepinder Goyal's Zomato, here is the list of Indian companies that recently rebranded
Life Insurance Quotes Explained: Guide to securing your family’s financial future
Winter Essentials: Must-have home appliances to keep you warm, cozy
'Ishq Na Kario' Releases: Abhishek Kumar takes his first step in cinema
Roadmap to building Rs 5 crore retirement corpus with NPS
Sri Lanka suffers nationwide power outage due to monkey, know what exactly happened
Fatima Sana Shaikh makes this BIG claim about male actors, says, 'If Shah Rukh Khan...'
The Visionary Behind Modern Data Platforms: Shreesha Hegde’s blueprint for industry success
Sam Nujoma passes away at 95: Know all about Namibia's fiery freedom fighter and first president
'Jahan Kaam, Wahan hum': PM Modi pitches leadership mantra to students during Pariksha Pe Charcha
Raheja Developer's 42-floor The Leela Sky Villas to bring ultra-luxury to Central West Delhi
Cristiano Ronaldo doesn't have any tattoos, reason will leave you SHOCKED, it is...
Prayagraj sees 300-km-long traffic jam, leave devotees without food, water amid Mahakumbh
Tirupati Laddu Prasadam row: CBI arrests four people in ghee adulteration case
JEE Mains 2025 Result: NTA JEE Session 1 result to be declared on..., know how to download scorecard
Donald Trump reveals BIG plan, says committed to 'buy and own' Gaza, allow others to...
Did Lionel Messi’s son Thiago score 11 goals in single match for Inter Miami? Here's the truth
India vs England: Rohit Sharma goes past Chris Gayle in all-time ODI list led by Shahid Afridi
Ed Sheeran BREAKS silence after Bengaluru cops stop his street performance: 'It wasn't just...'
India gains, Pakistan struggles: Forex reserves rise to Rs 55300044 crore, Pak's decline continues
IND vs ENG: Rohit Sharma returns to form before Champions Trophy, slams 32nd ODI century vs England
'Mummy daantegi...': Little boy screams as tiger pulls his shirt at zoo, WATCH viral video
Manipur CM N Biren resigns nearly two years after ethnic violence in state
Viral Video: Women travel in train toilet to Maha Kumbh, internet says "Is this a joke?