Haryanvi singer Fazilpuria targeted in roadside firing in Gurugram
Kavya Maran makes BIG change in SRH, appoints this former India speedster as..., he is...
Elon Musk's Grok inks deal worth $200 with Pentagon amid fallout with Donald Trump
UPSC CSE Mains 2025 schedule out, to be held on THESE dates, check full timetable
Amritsar’s Golden Temple receives bomb threat, email says...; police beef up security
Watch Shubhanshu Shukla showcasing stunning zero-gravity experiments on board ISS using...
Who was Fauja Singh, 114-year-old veteran marathon runner, dies in road accident?
Meet man who is set to lead India's largest insurer company worth Rs 579000 crore as...
Viral video: Couple caught throwing trash in Canadian forest, netizens say 'impose fine'
Donald Trump issues BIG warning to Putin, says will impose 'very severe' tariffs on Russia if...
R Ashwin reveals real reason behind sending Akash Deep as nighwatchman in Lord's test
Trouble mounts for PTI’s Imran Khan, govt makes new force to tackle protest
BIG move by DGCA after Air India plane crash report, directs all airlines to...
Bangladesh: Protests against Muhammad Yunus after Hindu trader was lynched by Muslim mob
After 15000 layoffs at Microsoft, now Bill Gates' company wants remaining employees to master...
After decades in US, 53-year-old man wonders if It's time to return to Mumbai
India's retail inflation eases to over six-year low in June at 2.1%
Meet man, IIT alumni, left Rs 10000000 IT job due to..., he now does...
Wimbledon celebrates Jannik Sinner's historic win with Thalapathy Vijay's Jana Nayagan-inspired post
Largest ever military exercise: Where is it taking place? Is Indian Army participating in it?
Turn your TV into computer with Mukesh Ambani's another masterstroke, Reliance Jio launches...
9 Meme Coins Under $1 That Can Make Millionaires in the Next 6 Months
Meet man who studied 10 hours daily battling shoulder pain, cracked CA at the age of...
Radhika Yadav case: Tennis player's Instagram account surfaces, cryptic bio raises questions
Good news for Bhavish Aggarwal as Ola Electric's net loss narrowed to Rs...; share jumps to Rs...
Man in Assam goes viral after celebrating divorce with 40-litre milk bath: 'Happy Independence Day'
BIG trouble for Mohammed Siraj, ICC fines India's star pacer 15% of match fee due to...
Who is Rayyan Arkan Dikha? Indonesian boy whose ‘aura farming’ dance is taking over the internet
Meet singer who shook Bollywood by marrying his guru’s wife, was boycotted, then...; his name is...
SC's BIG statement on Kerala nurse Nimisha Priya's July 16 execution in Yemen, says...
Legendary Kannada actress Saroja Devi dies in Bengaluru
Meet boy, who spent 2 pears preparing for JEE to achieve his IIT dream, got admission in…
2 of India's favourite snacks enter health alert list, know which are these and why
Who was San Rechal? Former Miss Puducherry known for challenging skin bias, who died by suicide
Popular model San Rechal dies by suicide at 26
Three schools in Delhi receive bomb threat, probe underway
Kashish Kapoor alleges cook assaulted her, breaks down: 'He pinned me...'
IND vs ENG 3rd Test: Shubman Gill achieves milestone, breaks Rahul Dravid's 23-year-old record of...
Axiom-4 to undock from ISS today, Astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla set to return from space on...
Delhi-NCR weather today: National capital wakes up to light shower, IMD issues red alert for...
INDIA
Now don’t jump up and get nervous, but at this very moment you could be under surveillance. Someone may be watching you.
NEW DELHI: Now don't jump up and get nervous, but at this very moment you could be under surveillance. Someone may be watching you, your phone may be tapped, or someone may have hacked into your email. Or maybe when you went to the milk booth this morning, your movements were captured by a hidden camera.
Inquiries, investigations, and sources have revealed that a staggeringly high number of telephones are tapped in the country, often without authorisation. Similar illegal activities, mostly by agencies of the state, are underway to hack into your email, monitor your Internet chats, and record your movements.
These intrusions, signs of a growing police state, will only increase as terrorism remains the biggest worry of governments, even though such steps may not be the most effective way of checking the faceless, stateless enemy.
Telecom industry sources told DNA that the number of wiretaps could be as high as 1 per cent of all calls in a day. Most of these are illegal, which means they are carried out without proper authorisation.
Though there is no accurate figure for the number of calls made in a day, data of phone traffic in minutes indicate that it could top 1 billion. This means at least 10 million calls are tapped every day.
Pavan Duggal, leading cyber law expert, believes the figure could be higher because, in sensitive places like Delhi, Mumbai, and Jammu & Kashmir, the pace of random tapping is higher. He believes almost 2 per cent of all calls are under surveillance. "Tapping is crucial for ensuring the country's security," he says, "but adherence to the parameters is very important."
Leading criminal lawyer and human rights activist Nandita Haksar says the situation is worrisome. While the police and army are "accountable in some way", it is the intelligence agencies that are misusing the system and randomly intruding privacy, says Haksar who has handled many sensitive cases, including that of Delhi University lecturer SAR Geelani, who was acquitted by the Supreme Court in the December 13 Parliament attack case.
"The intelligence agencies are not accountable in any way," says Haksar, "and in no way can we make them accountable."
All intelligence agencies of the government have dedicated facilities to tap phones as well as teams of computer experts who can hack through sophisticated data protection walls.
Among key evidence presented against Geelani were details of his telephone conversations. But one of the defence exhibits, a stunning admission of the recklessness of the capital's police force, went largely unnoticed. It was a top-secret memo that Police Commissioner KK Paul had written in 2002, when he was special commissioner in charge of intelligence.
The memo said "several complaints have been received" from private mobile companies against the city police of the way they deal with them. "Members of the public" are obtaining details of phone calls of "opponents in trade or estranged spouses" misusing local police contacts, it said.
Paul's memo said phone companies "extended facilities for listening on the understanding that formal requisition, after obtaining the approval of a competent authority, will be given immediately". But in many cases it is "not given even the next day" and in some cases "never at all".
There is significant incidence of official tapping also, on the order of a home or chief secretary. Such tapping is mainly to safeguard national security and crack abduction, smuggling, and narcotics cases. For instance, in a state that is not considered sensitive, about 150 individuals are on the wiretap list at any given time, a high-level source, who asked not to be named, said. "Sensitive and border states record much higher numbers of taps," he said.
While government officials, serving and former, do not rule out random taps, they insist that "the rules and procedures for tapping phones are quite well set". One source said, "The agencies concerned are careful about following the laws of the land, but in some cases the latest technology and equipment could outpace official procedures."
Police and intelligence officers admit that it is easier to get private telecom firms to do their bidding. But senior officials at these companies and industry associations refuse to give any figures on wiretaps. Asked about unofficial wiretaps, Cellular Operators Association of India director-general TV Ramachandran said, "I think such tapping is very rare." He added that "there could be times when immediate tapping is necessary, but authorisation may come later. You can't call that unauthorised tapping."
Telecom Regulatory Authority of India chairman Pradip Baijal said he has no information on the number of taps. "Tapping phones is not my job," he said. "It's the job of intelligence agencies and the police."
SK Dutta, former director of the Central Bureau of Investigation, said, "Phones have taken over our jobs. It's the US way of doing things. In India we are still in the human phase of intelligence gathering, but we are inching towards it."
While Dutta was surprised at the high number of wiretaps "that you are talking about", he said it was unavoidable. There are so many international criminal enterprises and introducing a mole is very difficult.
Experts, meanwhile, blame outdated laws and lack of protection for the ordinary citizen. Tapping of phones is regulated by the Telegraph Act of 1885. "How do I protect myself? Whom do I complain to? What evidence do I have?" says Haksar.
It is a growing chorus, but there is not much hope on the horizon.