INDIA
Arvind Datar also said that “in 9 out of the 19 tribunals, the parent ministries/departments are also a party to the proceedings before such tribunals
The insertion of a Section to amend and replace substantive provisions relating to appointment, selection and other service conditions of 19 Tribunals in the form of a 'money bill' suffers from procedural illegality, smacks of constitutional impropriety and amounts to fraud on the Constitution.
The rules for appointing members to tribunals are contradictory to the established law set by the Supreme Court and structured in a way that would dissuade competent judges and lawyers from applying for these posts, senior advocate Arvind Datar said in his submission to the Supreme Court.
In compliance with the December 15, 2017 order, the Centre had filed an affidavit with a proposal to modify the Tribunal Rules on January 4, 2018. In the December order, the apex court had also directed amicus curiae Datar and advocate Mohan Parasaran "to peruse the same and, if necessary, point out anything contrary to the learned Attorney General before the matter is taken up by the court".
After perusing the draft, Datar filed his objections to the draft of amended rules suggesting that the rules in the Finance Act, and the draft of amended rules create a system that is a branch of the executive and not the judiciary.
Apart from losing its independence, senior advocate Arvind Datar observed that even though the Centre was attempting to create a huge quasi-judicial eco-system to ease the burdens on courts, this eco-system has not been given independence or able organisational support.
"The selection committee for appointment of members to the tribunals include secretaries in the ministries of the relevant tribunals," Datar said. "The delegation of substantive powers to frame rules relating to eligibility, selection and other service conditions to the central government is excessive, arbitrary and affects the independence of the tribunals."
In his 11-page affidavit, Datar also said that "in 9 out of the 19 tribunals, however, the parent ministries/departments are also a party to the proceedings before such tribunals, and hence, there is a high possibility that the secretary would be a party to such list. This shows that the tribunals are functioning under ministries/departments against which they would have to pass orders. Therefore, ministries that are parties to proceedings before such tribunals established under it must not be a part of the selection process or even provide for any financial support or hold any administrative control of those tribunals".
Datar also pointed out that there was no uniform criteria, composition or methodology of the selection committees. For 12 out of 19 tribunals, moreover, the composition of the selection committee for the post of a chairperson and members also differ.
The Chief Justice was party to a few selection committees. However, the representation from the judiciary on the committee is in the ratio of 1:4 or 1:5, thereby giving no primacy to views of the Chief Justice or his nominee. In few other tribunals, the selection committees for members do not include any representation from the judiciary.
Datar pointed out that in more than two decades, no steps have been initiated by the Ministry of Law & Justice to take over the functioning of the tribunals.
The secretary of the relevant/parent ministry acts as the convener of their respective search-cum-selection committees as per RULE 4(2). As a result, meetings, deliberations, advertisements, and other secretarial aspects of the appointments are entirely under the control of the parent ministry/department.
NHAI clarifies on new FASTag rules, says customers can recharge...
Man sues PVR, INOX for wasting time with 25-min ads, wins Rs...
Red Coral and Yellow Sapphire: A Powerful Combination or Not?
Narayana Murthy's Infosys makes BIG announcement ahead of annual salary hike, offers lower...
Parthiv Patel's self deprecating humour wins hearts, he was asked about Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma
Ramadan 2025 date: When will crescent moon sighting take place in India and Saudi Arabia?
Mamaearth co-founder Ghazal Alagh says every successful brand has one thing in common, it is...
Neo Ayurveda Resolves 20-Year Migraines and Normalizes TSH in Just 30 Days
After backlash, Netflix cuts Urvashi Rautela's role from Daaku Maharaaj? Here's what we know
Mukesh Ambani's popular brand enters quick e-commerce delivery in UAE, teams up with...
On the Epic 8th Anniversary, Lystloc Launches Advanced LystCRM Solution & Face Rec API
Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg gets richer by Rs 118 crore after selling...; his net worth reaches Rs...
Nagaland Lottery Result February 19: Dear Cupid Wednesday lucky draw, check full list
Pak vs NZ, Champions Trophy 2025: Disaster for Pakistan? Fakhar Zaman is off the field in first over
Who was Milind Rege? Former Mumbai stalwart and selector who passed away at 76
Food vlogger, Chatori Rajani's 17-year-old son Taran Jain dies in road accident
Pak vs NZ Dream11 predictions: Check best picks for ICC Champions Trophy 2025's opening match
Varun Dhawan suffers injury, shares photo of deep cut on his finger: 'This one gets...'
Meet man, who joined NVIDIA in 1997, helped it become USD 3 trillion company amid US-China AI war
Asap Rocky found not guilty of shooting at former friend, Rihanna reacts: 'The glory belongs to...'
LIC Smart Pension Plan: Invest Rs 1 lakh and get Rs... every month on maturity, here's how
Influencer recreates Katrina Kaif's dialogue from Tees Maar Khan and it's absolutely on point
Future of Pilot Ejection: Martin-Baker's advanced technology comes to India
Meet Infosys co-founder Narayana Murthy, Sudha Murty's granddaughters, their famous parents are...
FWICE urges Maharashtra government to make Vicky Kaushal, Rashmika Mandanna's Chhaava tax-free
Priyanka Chopra gives major Rangeela vibes as she channels her 'inner Urmila Matondkar'
Jamie Lever mimicking Govinda's wife Sunita Ahuja will start your day with laughter
Watch: Priyanka Chopra lands in Mumbai days after brother’s wedding, helps a person on streets by…
'They have a lot more money': Trump questions USD 21 million fund for voter turnout in India
Bank Holiday Today: Banks to remain closed on February 19 in THIS state due to...
Donald Trump signs executive order to expand access to IVF
Meet woman, who left her medical career for husband who became one of India's richest men
Meet IPS officer, who has been demoted due to his 2nd marriage; here's why
How Elon Musk became world's richest man with Rs 33 lakh crore business empire
DNA TV Show: Conflicting data on Delhi station stampede reveals communication gap
WATCH: Baba Ramdev at 59 takes part in race with horse, netizens say 'Olympics me chalo'
Delhi woman turns auto driver to support daughter, her story goes viral
Viral video declares Rajat Patidar ‘Captain of Captains’ after RCB names him Skipper, here's why
Indian Army havildar loses teen son, saves others’ lives by...
WPL 2025: Smriti Mandhana creates history during RCB vs DC match, becomes first player to cross...
Ronit Roy says he was the first choice for Pardes but he was replaced by...because...
‘Papa killed mummy': 4-year-old's drawing creates suspicion over woman’s alleged suicide
How a low cost floor cleaning robot revolutinising home automation – Check details
Harvard Alum Aayush Puri: Move back to India, the future is here
Vicky Kaushal reveals how his fight scene with lion in Chhaava was shot: 'We were all so...'
Shabana Azmi holds her ears, issues public apology to Dabba Cartel co-star Jyotika; here's why