EXPLAINER
Recently, the Supreme Court commuted the death sentence of a man, convicted of the rape and murder of a seven-year-old girl, to life imprisonment.
In a big development, the Supreme Court has suo motu opened a review of the process by which courts award the death penalty. The apex court will consider laying down guidelines for assessment of mitigating circumstances in death penalty cases as it raised concerns on the process.
Recently, the Supreme Court commuted the death sentence of a man, convicted of the rape and murder of a seven-year-old girl, to life imprisonment. This judgment may become a significant precedent to the anti-death penalty cause. SC had decided to extensively examine the circumstances where a judge had to choose between life imprisonment and death penalty.
The apex court commuted the death sentence to life imprisonment, saying the guilty shall not be entitled to 'premature release or remission before undergoing actual imprisonment' for a period of 30 years.
It advised the trial judges that they should not be swayed in favour of death penalty merely because of the dreadful nature of the crime and its harmful impact on the society. They should equally consider the mitigating factors in favour of life imprisonment.
Read | No public executions and hanging of bodies in Afghanistan - Taliban's new diktat
Death penalty, also known as capital punishment, is the execution of an offender sentenced to death after conviction by a court of law of a criminal offence. It is the highest penalty awardable to an accused. In India, death penalty it is awarded in extremely severe cases of murder, rapes, treason etc.
Under the provisions of criminal procedure, death penalty must be awarded as an alternative punishment to life imprisonment which the offenders may be sentenced in 'rarest of rare cases'. It is seen as the most suitable punishment and effective deterrent for the worst crimes.
Rarest of rare cases can be described as those when the murder is committed in an extremely brutal, ridiculous, diabolical, revolting, or reprehensible manner so as to awaken intense and extreme indignation of the community. When total depravity and cruelty are the motives behind a murder.
Crimes punishable by death in India include aggravated murder, other offences resulting in death, terrorism-related crimes resulting in death, terrorism-related cases not resulting in death, rape not resulting in death, kidnapping not resulting in death, drug trafficking not resulting in death, treason, espionage and military offenses not resulting in death.
Retribution - One of the key principles of retribution is that people should get what they deserve in proportion to the severity of their crime. This argument states that real justice requires people to suffer for their wrongdoing and to suffer in a way appropriate for the crime.
Deterrence - Capital punishment is often justified with the argument that by executing convicted murderers, we will deter would-be murderers from killing people. It is often argued that the death penalty provides closure for victims' families.
The statistical evidence doesn't confirm that deterrence works. Some of those executed may not have been capable of being deterred because of mental illness or defect. Death has been prescribed in rape cases since 2013 (Sec. 376A of IPC), still, rapes continue to happen and in fact, the brutality of rapes has increased manifold. This compels one to think of the death penalty is an effective deterrent to crime.
The most common argument against capital punishment is that sooner or later, innocent people may get killed, because of mistakes or flaws in the justice system. According to Amnesty International, as long as human justice remains fallible, the risk of executing the innocent can never be eliminated.
Those who oppose it, however, see it as inhumane. Thus, the morality of the death penalty is debatable and many criminologists and socialists all across the globe, have been long demanding abolition of the death penalty.
Death has been abolished as a form of punishment in most of the developed countries. Capital punishment does not rehabilitate the prisoner and return them to society.
Jagmohan Singh vs State of UP 1973 case - SC held that according to Article 21 deprivation of life is constitutionally permissible if that is done according to the procedure established by law. Thus the death sentence imposed after a trial in accordance with legally established procedures under Cr.PC and the Indian Evidence Act 1872 is not unconstitutional under Article 21.
Rajendra Prasad vs State of UP 1979 case - SC held that, if the murderous operation of a criminal jeopardizes social security in a persistent, planned and perilous fashion then his enjoyment of fundamental rights may be rightly annihilated.
Bachan Singh vs the State of Punjab 1980 case - SC propounded the dictum of ‘rarest of rare cases’ according to which death penalty is not to be awarded except in the 'rarest of rare cases' when the alternative option is unquestionably foreclosed.
Machhi Singh vs State of Punjab 1983 case - The Supreme Court laid down certain considerations for determining whether a case falls under the category of rarest of rare cases or not.
Sustainability Takes Center Stage in US Manufacturing with Leader Viralsinh Solanki at the Forefront
How to Crack the CTET Exam in 1st Attempt?
'Trump visits India': Man perfectly mimics Donald Trump's 'love' for India, watch viral video
Manipur: 11 suspected militants killed in gunfight with security forces in Jiribam
Ram Gopal Varma booked for offensive posts against Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu
Will MrBeast make a video with Virat Kohli? World's biggest YouTuber drops massive hint
This cricketer once walked out to bat with an aluminium bat against England, refused to...
Bigg Boss 18: Rajat Dalal shuts down Vivian Dsena, says 'tera naukar thodi hoon'
Meet actor who cheated on wife with multiple women, got divorced, remarried same woman but...
Aryan to Anaya: Ex-Indian cricketer, coach's son undergoes sex change surgery
Shillong Teer Result OUT for November 11, 2024: First and second round Monday lottery results here
How US Vice President-elect JD Vance found love in Indian-origin Usha Chilukuri, know their story
Maruti Suzuki launches new Dzire: Check price, features of Tata Tiago, Honda Amaze rival
Sebi’s Rs 25 crore penalty plea against Mukesh Ambani dismissed by SC in THIS case
Big blow to former JD(S) MP Prajwal Revanna as SC denies bail in rape case
6,6,6,6,6,4,4,4,4,4: Shubman Gill's MASSIVE 268 runs in Ranji against...
Berjis Desai’s crime thriller “Murder at the Racecourse” keeps you on the edge
'We went totally wrong...': Rohit Shetty opens up on casting Arjun Kapoor in Singham Again
Shah Rukh Khan's Marjaani gets BTS makeover, watch Jungkook, V, Suga's viral dance
'India's finest': Netizens pour in emotional tributes as Vistara readies for last flight today
Vistara to make last flight today before Air India merger, all you need to know
Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal offers job to X user who suggested THIS BIG change
What is Mukesh Ambani, Nita Ambani's son Anant Ambani's annual salary? Know all about his net worth
Veteran actor Delhi Ganesh cremated with Air Force honours, here's why
'We got the...': Germany grooves to Marathi song Taambdi Chamdi, netizens go berserk; WATCH
Kamal Hassan asks fans to not call him 'Ulaganayagan', says 'this decision comes from....'
'I fell and it went...': Vijay Deverakonda REACTS after video of him falling down stairs goes viral
BIG update on Rohit Sharma's participation in 1st Test against Australia, he is all set to…
Justice Sanjiv Khanna takes oath as 51st Chief Justice of India
Ajay Devgn spills the beans on his 14-year-old son Yug's love life, says 'he is not afraid....'
11/11: Why November 11 is a good day for manifestation? Know how, when you can manifest today
Onion prices rise to Rs 80 per kg: Check rates in Delhi-NCR, Mumbai, Chennai
Guru Purab Bank Holiday November 15: Are banks open or closed on Guru Nanak Jayanti?
Meet Indian genius, world's youngest female Chartered Accountant who secured AIR 1, she is from...
Delhi continues to choke amid rising air pollution, AQI breaches 350...
Avatar 3: New posters of James Cameron's film feature fire tribe, stunning visuals go viral
This country lets male tourists marry women for a few days due to....
Maharashtra polls: Congress suspends seven more rebel candidates
Meet man who quit high-paying job in US, then built Rs 150 crore company in India, his business is…
Viral video: Little girl wins heart with adorable dance to 'aayi nai' song, watch
Queen Elizabeth's 1947 wedding cake slice sold in auction at this SHOCKING price
Viral video: Woman's sizzling dance to 'tere liye' leaves internet drooling, watch
Meet man who leads Rs 185985 crore company as CEO, son of Indian billionaire, he is...
'We don't encourage...': Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal launches new feature 'Food Rescue' to reduce...
Before Pakistani TikTok star Minahil Malik, actress Rida Isfahani's MMS video leaked online by...
Watch: Virat Kohli gets annoyed at Mumbai airport, asks paps to stay away from…
Watch: David Miller's spectacular one-handed catch shocks Tilak Varma in IND vs SA 2nd T20I
Do you see 11:11? What's the secret behind this number?
'Najar Na Lage': Sidhu Moosewala’s parents perform annaprashan ceremony for chota Sidhu, watch
Baba Siddique murder case: Main shooter, 4 others arrested in UP