BUSINESS
With newer entrants backed by foreign players ramping up service, rock-bottom tariffs continue to fall to the detriment of Bharti Airtel, Reliance Comm and Vodafone's Indian unit.
Consolidation in the 15-player market, which is the world's second-largest with more than 600 million users and growing by 16 million a month, looks at least a year away unless rules change.
Just-completed auctions for 3G and broadband airwaves cost far more than expected. They also reintroduced an unpredictable 900-pound gorilla to the market in Mukesh Ambani's Reliance Industries,
With newer entrants backed by foreign players such as Telenor, Sistema and Etisalat ramping up service, rock-bottom tariffs continue to fall, to the detriment of market leaders Bharti Airtel, Reliance Communications and Vodafone's Indian unit.
"With 12 players in the circle it would be too bullish to expect that 12 players will behave rationally," said Vsevolod Rozanov, president and CEO of Sistema Shyam Teleservices, the Russian firm's Indian subsidiary, whose ongoing rollout will be bolstered by a $600 million investment by the Russian government.
"Of course price erosion will continue," he said.
The stress is showing, and not just on investors who have seen share prices fall by more than half from peaks for Bharti and Idea Cellular, and 76% for Reliance Comm.
"If anything, a lot of these telecom operators may get in some source of funding overseas and their ability to compete in the near term only increases rather than decreases," said Prateek Agrawal, head of equities at Bharti Axa Mutual Fund in Mumbai.
Both Bharti and Vodafone lashed out over a recent regulatory proposal to price additional 2G spectrum based on 3G prices.
Bharti, 32% owned by Singapore Telecommunications, reported its first quarterly profit drop in three years and is hedging its
Consolidation would improve the landscape for carriers, but rules prohibit them from selling out within three years of receiving licenses, which means the class of 2008 must stay in the game at least until next year. Eventually, industry watchers expect the sector to be culled to six or seven players.
Reliance Comm is selling its tower arm in a deal that will cut its debt by more than half but is still trying to unload a 26% stake to a wary global market. Only Etisalat of Abu Dhabi has expressed interest. Other would-be investors - MTN, AT&T and Vivendi - have shot down reports based on unnamed sources saying they were talking to Reliance Comm.
This should have been a golden age for carriers in an Indian market where mobile penetration only recently crossed 50% and lags only
A key difference:
The problem for Indian carriers is regulatory, some argue:
Auctions for 3G and broadband spectrum that netted the government $21.6 billion may have made the situation worse by adding to costs and bringing in more players. Carriers who sought pan-India 3G coverage were thwarted by the high cost.
So far, operators have managed to find capital, with local banks stumping up funding for 3G licenses. Carriers and their investors hope that with increased use of data services and rising incomes, operators will some day earn far more per user in a market with call rates now as low as 0.4 US cents a minute.
Bharti, Reliance Comm, Idea and Vodafone Essar saw combined average revenue per user (ARPU) fall 30% to Rs185 ($4) a month in the March quarter from a year earlier, according to Nomura. China Mobile, the dominant player in its market, generated ARPU of 70 yuan ($10.30) in the same quarter.
Seth Freeman, CEO of EM Capital Management in
Less clear is the effect broadband wireless technology will have on competition, including for voice service. In a country where broadband penetration is below one line per 100 people, the potential is vast.
"You clearly will see over the next two years the wireless data business come into a lot more prominence," said
The return to telecoms of Mukesh Ambani, the world's fourth-richest man, is the wild card. His Reliance Industries (RIL) conglomerate was free to return to telecoms after he and his long-estranged brother, Anil, ended a pact last month that forbade them from competing on the other's turf.
Anil Ambani controls Reliance Comm, after the two brothers split up the family business empire five years ago.
"Given RIL's access to cash, its prior experience in the Indian telecoms sector and ability to navigate the minefield of Indian regulations, we believe the company could significantly disrupt the Indian wireless space," Credit Suisse analysts wrote.
That's the last thing incumbent operators want to hear.
Indian Army havildar loses teen son, saves others’ lives by...
WPL 2025: Smriti Mandhana creates history during RCB vs DC match, becomes first player to cross...
Ronit Roy says he was the first choice for Pardes but he was replaced by...because...
‘Papa killed mummy': 4-year-old's drawing creates suspicion over woman’s alleged suicide
Sunil Mittal gets Rs 8486 crore after selling....; still seeks funds for newer...
How a low cost floor cleaning robot revolutinising home automation – Check details
Harvard Alum Aayush Puri: Move back to India, the future is here
Vicky Kaushal reveals how his fight scene with lion in Chhaava was shot: 'We were all so...'
Shabana Azmi holds her ears, issues public apology to Dabba Cartel co-star Jyotika; here's why
Meet Arvind Kejriwal’s daughter, who cracked IIT-JEE Advanced, went to IIT Delhi, now working as...
'Kohli never said a word': Pakistan's Haris Rauf on Virat Kohli hitting sixes against him in...
Bengaluru to witness hottest summer says IMD, recorded season’s highest temperature at...
Ranveer Singh to venture in production amid box office slump? Here's the truth
Where to Buy Testosterone in the USA? Top 3 Best Brands of Testosterone Cypionate in 2025
Pregnant woman employee gets Rs 1 crore compensation after being fired through...
ELECRAMA 2025: Powering the Future of Energy
Steroids for Sale in the USA: Buy Steroids Online in 2025
How to Choose Trenbolone for Sale Online? Review of Popular Trenbolone Manufacturers
After disrupting Indian market, Mukesh Ambani takes THIS popular brand to...
Remedium Lifecare Lands Rs 182 Crore Multi-Year Contract: Stock Set for Major Upturn
Former ISRO chief AS Kiran Kumar visits Goenka Temple, expresses hope for successful Mars mission
Anil Ambani's Rs 9831 crore company set to enter NEW space, makes key...
Vladimir Putin's BIG warning to Ukraine, will negotiate only if...
347 rooms, Rs 22400 crore worth: India's most expensive wedding venue is located in...
Woman constable carries baby on duty, RPSF says, 'she serves, she...', video goes viral
'Caught Red-Handed': Cognizant accuses Narayana Murthy's Infosys of stealing THIS secret in...
'Bharat Jodo Vivah': Wedding invite of Jammu's daughter, Kerala's son wows internet
Pavitra Rishta fame Usha Nadkarni cries inconsolably as she remembers her brother's death, watch
MASSIVE discount on Apple iPhone 16, iPhone 15, check here how to grab this deal
Juhi Chawla takes holy dip at Mahakumbh 2025, calls it 'most beautiful morning in her life'
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato launches first AI product ‘Nugget,’ says will give it for free to…
Champions Trophy 2025: 5 major records that Virat Kohli can break in this tournament
Shweta Basu Prasad says she was bullied on Telugu film set: 'I was called...'
Gujarat: Lion brings traffic to a halt at Bhavnagar-Somnath highway, watch viral video
India's Got Latent row: SC grants interim relief from arrest to Ranveer Allahbadia
Tesla begins hiring in India after PM Modi-Musk meet, announces multiple job roles in...
Gurugram woman shares interview experience at Zomato, CEO Deepinder Goyal reacts, says...
'Sir ek kiss ho jaye': Paps unleash a horror welcome on Udit Narayan
Salman Khan, Sanjay Dutt REUNITE for Hollywood thriller, filming begins in Saudi Arabia: Report
Gujarat: Videos of women patients leaked on Telegram, YouTube, probe ordered
South Korean actress Kim Sae-ron found dead at home, cause of death revealed
Canada: Delta Airlines plane crashes at Toronto Pearson airport, flips upside down, several injured
Meet Gyanesh Kumar, IIT graduate, who becomes new Chief Election Commissioner
DNA TV Show: RSS' Bihar model ahead of Assembly elections in state
WPL 2025: Renuka, Wareham spark collapse as RCB bowl out Delhi Capitals for 141
Champions Trophy 2025: Ex-Pak cricketer says Pakistan don't deserve to win, 'Chal jaaye toh...'
Samantha Ruth Prabhu's Dippam Dappam dance leaves Chennai students awestruck, viral video
Breaking MS Dhoni's record is no big deal for Dinesh Karthik: 'It’s not something...'
Amid Mahakumbh rush, video of vehicle running on railway track goes viral; here's why