Advertisement
Latest NewsBusiness

CEA questions rating agencies' double standards on India, China

They rated India too low despite fundamental improvement compared to China. The rating agencies have been inconsistent in their treatment of China and India: Arvind Subramanian

Latest News
CEA questions rating agencies' double standards on India, China
Add DNA as a Preferred Source

India's chief economic adviser (CEA) Arvind Subramanian has said that international rating agencies are biased and have almost lost their credibility, especially regarding India.

"They rated India too low despite fundamental improvement compared to China. The rating agencies have been inconsistent in their treatment of China and India," Subramanian said without naming any agencies.

International rating agencies have given India a BBB- rating, just above the junk grade and the lowest among investment grade ratings despite improvements in economic fundamentals like inflation, growth, and current account performance. But the same time, China's rating has upgraded to AA-, even its fundamentals have not supported it.

Subramanian said in the US financial crisis, questions were raised about their role in certifying as AAA bundles of mortgage-backed securities that had toxic underlying assets.

Further, "their value has been questioned in light of their failure to provide warnings in advance of financial crises", he said.

Often rating downgrade has occurred post facto, a case of closing the stable doors after the horses have bolted.

Singapore-based Thomas Labbe, a fixed income market expert with Bloomberg who had worked with Morgan Stanley, has said because the raters tend to focus on long-term trends, their verdicts on creditworthiness may lag behind developments.

He explained that how independent models can be especially useful in countries like India where market priced credit risk differs from ratings. He has taken the example of a 10-year Indian government bond that matures in 2027 yielded 7.45% as of March 10. He analysed yield and spread function in terms of the yield into a US-dollar-denominated equivalent bond. He picked up the March 10th 2017 data of the Indian bond which traded at a 69-basis-point spread over the US Treasury bond. Labbe has compared the similar Malaysian bond which matures in 2027 too and shows that Malaysian bond's yield was only 4.29%. He also converted the return into US dollar and found 'a spread of 64 basis points over the Treasury bond'. In spite of the solid performance, "India is rated Baa3, BBB-, and BBB- by the three main rating companies" and "Malaysia is rated A3, A-, and A-."

Find your daily dose of All Latest News including Sports News, Entertainment News, Lifestyle News, explainers & more. Stay updated, Stay informed- Follow DNA on WhatsApp.
Read More
Advertisement
Advertisement

Advertisement