ANALYSIS
Aadhaar, with several loopholes, has become an embarrassment for the government.
On September 23, two judges of the Supreme Court directed that “no person should suffer for not getting the Aadhaar card”. Why did the court need to say this?
In 2009 and 2010, when the project had just been launched, enrolment was promoted as being voluntary. It was marketed as a convenience for those who already had other forms of identity; and a boon to those without any identity document, with the poor as the primary constituency. It was presented as a means to practise ‘inclusion’, that is, those for whom benefits and subsidies had been out of reach because they had no means of identifying themselves to the State and other private entities would now have an identity.
Yet, the small print, even then, was saying something else.
In April 2010, the Strategy Overview document of the UIDAI read: “UID will not be mandated: The UIDAI approach will be a demand-driven one, where the benefits and services that are linked to the UID will ensure demand for the number. This will not, however, preclude governments or Registrars from mandating enrolment.” So, making the UID mandatory was intended; only, the UID would work on, and with, Registrars to introduce the element of compulsion. This allowed the UIDAI to keep talking about ‘inclusion’, while governments and their departments would be egged on to bully people into enrolling for a UID on threat of exclusion from services.
Take the proposed linking up between the UID and the PDS in a UIDAI document titled (no marks for guessing) UID and PDS. “To support enrolment, the central government will mandate that the UID numbers of each family member should be recorded in the ration card and the data base should be made available” to the UIDAI. That is quite unambiguous!
Its document titled UID and Public Health has this: “Every citizen must have a strong incentive or a “killer application” to go and get herself a UID, which one could think of as a demand side pull. The demand side pull needs to be created de novo or fostered on existing platforms by the respective ministries. Helping various ministries visualise key applications that leverage existing government entitlement schemes such as the PDS and the NREGA will (1) get their buy-in into the project (2) help them roll out mechanisms that generate the demand pull....”.
These are documents that have been around since 2009-10, and the UIDAI has been hard at work getting governments and agencies to link the UID number to all manner of services.
Why does it matter that the UID is made mandatory? One, there is yet no law that covers this project. The UIDAI has been saying that should not matter because they were set up by an executive order, and that should be quite enough. That is a wholly questionable proposition, and it is, in fact, under challenge in court. But, the fact that a law was in fact introduced in Parliament in December 2010, and the Standing Committee on Finance rejected it in a scathing report that asked that both the project and the law be sent back to the drawing board, cannot be glossed over. There is also no law protecting privacy; the idea of data about individuals being the new property is helped by trivialising the right to privacy.
Then, there is a startling fact that too few people have recognised: biometrics, which the UIDAI has been claiming can uniquely identify every individual, had not been tested when the project began. The decision was made on assumptions. This is not just a hypothesis.
Take a look at this: In a ‘notice inviting applications for hiring of biometrics consultant’ issued by the UIDAI in January/February 2010, the UIDAI admitted complete ignorance about the effectiveness of biometrics: “there is a lack of a sound study that documents the accuracy achievable on Indian demographics (that is, larger percentage of rural population) and in Indian environmental conditions (that is, extremely hot and humid climates and facilities without air-conditioning). In fact, we do not have any credible study assessing the achievable accuracy in any of the developing countries.... The ‘quality’ assessment of fingerprint data (in the UIDAI’s ‘preliminary assessment’) is not sufficient to fully understand the achievable de-duplication accuracy.” It was in this state of ignorance that the decision to make biometrics the ‘unique’ factor was made.
Today, three years later, it has become evident that old people and the poor are facing hurdles in authenticating themselves through biometrics. The UIDAI’s own authentication reports reveal how flawed the system is. More recently, the UIDAI has been talking of thousands of permanent enrolment stations, and people are advised to periodically re-enrol their fingerprints and iris. This is the first admission that biometrics are not forever, and that they change. Yet, the project refuses to pause. Making the UID mandatory in a system that cannot authenticate with any degree of certainty is only a prescription for massive exclusion. Why is no one in government verifying the field situation and asking the tough questions?
Direct Benefit Transfer has shown itself to be a mere excuse for making the UID mandatory. In Delhi and Maharashtra, for instance, registering a will or a rent agreement or a sale deed, or getting married, needs a UID. Government servants, and high court judges, in Maharashtra are not to get their salaries unless they are enrolled. In Kerala, children cannot be enrolled in schools. In Delhi, EWS category were threatened with exclusion.
Everywhere, gas subsidy is mandatorily linked with the UID number. And the list goes on.
It is no wonder that the court was asked to step in to stop this rampant and irresponsible use of a number produced through a deeply defective process.
The writer works on the jurisprudence of law, poverty and rights.
JEE Main 2025 Toppers List Released: Meet 14 candidates who scored 100 percentile this year
JEE Main Result 2025 DECLARED: Get direct link, steps to check NTA score and other details HERE
SHOCKING! Noida family held under ‘digital arrest’ for 5 days, loses Rs 1 crore to cyber fraud
Ranveer Singh, Akshaye Khanna shoot for Aditya Dhar's Dhurandhar in Mumbai, pictures get leaked
Why are hobby classes integral to Podar International School’s curriculum in Khopoli?
Mukesh Ambani buys Rs 6437604000 stake in THIS cricket team, not Mumbai Indians
World's richest man Elon Musk loses Rs 789330000000 in four days, net worth slips below Rs...
'Need global standards': PM Modi pushes for AI governance at Paris AI Summit
Ashutosh Rana slams Prabhas, Saif Ali Khan-starrer Adipurush: 'Audiences will not accept...'
Ahead of PM Modi-Donald Trump meet, India considers cutting tariffs on THESE items imported from US
Communication platforms are fast evolving into super apps
Mumbai Police reaches Ranveer Allahbadia's home in connection to India's Got Latent controversy
Junaid Khan says Aamir Khan, Reena Dutta spent ‘ridongculous’ amount on his...
Rohit Sharma, Rishabh Pant's warm gesture towards kid wins internet, watch viral video
Ajith Kumar recalls 'bad crash’ ahead of Portugal race: ‘When I crashed...'
India's Got Latent episode feat Ranveer Allahbadia blocked after government orders
Samay Raina performs in Seattle, enjoys with friends amid Ranveer Allahbadia controversy
Good news for Gautam Adani as Adani stocks rally up to 4.5% due to Donald Trump's this BIG move...
Amid rumours of dissent, AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal holds meeting with Punjab CM Mann, MLAs in Delhi
Woman makes 'Valentine edition parantha' for husband, netizens amused, watch viral video
How cashless treatment and telemedicine are transforming health insurance plans in India?
Top 3 astrologers of India: Newly updated list of 2025
A complete guide to documents needed for a personal loan
Mitolyn Reviews and Complaints - Mitolyn Supplement - Mitolyn Reviews Consumer Reports
Muslim wedding card goes viral for THIS bizarre reason, leaves netizens amused, check here
Surat: School students parade luxury cars to celebrate farewell, probe underway, watch viral video
Elon Musk offers this huge amount to buy ChatGPT maker OpenAI, Sam Altman says 'no thank you but...'
Pune: Pakistani currency note found in housing society near National Defence Academy; probe on
YouTube removes Ranveer Allahbadia's controversial video after Modi government's notice
Here's why Not Like Us singer Kendrick Lamar won't get paid for Super Bowl Halftime Show performance
Meet Samay Raina, creator of India's Got Latent, accused of promoting vulgarity, he is from...
Bank Holiday February 2025: Banks to remain closed in THIS state today due to...
Donald Trump issues BIG warning to Hamas, says 'all hell will break out' if...
Anil Ambani's RCap buy: Hinduja Group firm set to acquire debt-ridden Reliance Capital by THIS date
Meet man, MBA graduate from Harvard, who leads one of world’s big tech firms as CEO, he is...
Delhi-Dehradun Expressway opens, check travel time, toll fee and more
What happens during Snow Moon and when does it appear? Check dates and when to see
‘RBI’s gold buying is...’: FM Nirmala Sitharaman talks about rising gold reserves by central bank
Meet the Muslim king all set to challenge Donald Trump over Gaza, he is from...
Ranveer Allahbadia’s viral joke on Samay Raina's India's Got Latent was stolen! The original was...
THIS Indian billionaire carries coffin of his employee, netizens call him ‘true leader’
Days after Jeet Adani-Diva Shah's marriage, Gautam Adani set to spend Rs 6000 crore on...
'Please let me stay the night:' Female trainee asked to leave Infosys premises at 6 pm even after...
Auto driver’s son studies at IIT, but luxury hotel refuses his auto's entry, billionaire calls it...
Who is Kuldeep Sharma? Ex-IPS gets three-month jail term in...
Meet woman, who lived in village, later got job at Amazon, now working in US as...
Beef Biryani Row Explained: Police file FIR day after incident at AMU; here's what happened
Meet Anant Ahuja, Sonam Kapoor's brother-in-law who reportedly got Rs 6.56 cr by USAID
BIG move by Mukesh Ambani, launches Rs 10 product with former cricket star, it is...
Car gets stuck in wheat field in the dead of night, know what Google Maps error caused later
The Chabahar Puzzle: India’s Connectivity Dreams in US-Iran Turmoil
Delhi: Girls showcase their skills, strength in netball, Aali and Lal Kuan emerge winners
Elon Musk reacts to UK MP’s demand to replace 'Bengali' signboard at London Station, check here
Anupam Mittal's unique gift to Gautam Adani's son Jeet Adani will leave you in splits
Man dies after being sexually assaulted in Delhi, one arrested, this is what happened
After Deepinder Goyal's Zomato, here is the list of Indian companies that recently rebranded
Life Insurance Quotes Explained: Guide to securing your family’s financial future
Winter Essentials: Must-have home appliances to keep you warm, cozy