ANALYSIS
A spectre is falling across the metros of the Indian Republic. It is a menace that is sinister in its conception and tragic in its consequences.
A spectre is falling across the metros of the Indian Republic. It is a menace that is sinister in its conception and tragic in its consequences. The virtues of tolerance, freedom of expression, the right to privacy, the right to joy, the basic human impulse to feel alive and in doing so experiment with and experience the virtues and vices that make us human, are all under assault. One could be forgiven for assuming that the Indian state is at war with its best and brightest living in its metros. And its chosen instrument of waging this war is the police. If ‘I am Anna’ was the dominant meme of 2011 for India’s conscientious and concerned citizens, ‘I am Dhoble’ appears to be the comeback by the Indian state.
It seems to be the reality of policing in our metros. Come nightfall, and across our metros our men and women in khaki spread out on a sacred mission as shock troops of the new moral order. In this order, corruption and debauchery in the political and administrative arena is routinely ignored: It has to be, for it sustains and nourishes the system from which our jackboots derive the spring in their collective steps. Anywhere else, the challenges of terrorism, Naxalism, ethnic and communal violence, crimes against women and weaker sections would be seen as challenges enough for the police. But not us, we in the IPS have a weltanschauung that is defined in terms of might is right. It is a world view where freedom of expression, experimentation with choice in matters of sexuality, clothing, music and other forms of art and culture, use of legal and illegal intoxicants are seen as the biggest threats to the unity and integrity of India. A constabulary largely drawn from the rural peasantry, poorly educated, ill-trained and then dumped in inhuman working and living conditions, imbued with a deeply casteist, communalist and gender-biased outlook, that we do nothing to correct, is coming into contact with an educated, affluent and globalised citizenry. The result is a profound culture shock, unprovoked aggression and abuse of authority, stemming from feelings of envy, insecurity and ignorance.
ACP Vasant Dhoble is neither an original nor a pioneer. He is simply the most commonly occurring expression of the most dominant and destructive strands of the genetic makeup of the Indian Police. Sadly for all of us in the Indian Police, the old order changeth, and how.
The last 20 years have seen the emergence of an affluent, articulate, aware and globally inter-connected generation that is demanding strange things like rule of law, equality before law and a law that itself must be held to higher universal standards of rights and human dignity. They actually expect the police to serve as servants of the law with total public accountability. For us in the IPS, and for our bureaucratic and political masters, this is all terribly confusing and disorienting. Nobody told us.
In Mumbai and many other places, the police leadership takes the defence that it is merely upholding the law as it stands. This is humbug. There is a plethora of laws against corruption, against incitement to ethnic violence, against disruption of public order and destruction of public and private property. I wish we paid even a fraction of attention to the above laws compared to the speed and efficiency with which we went about shutting Mumbai’s dance bars in the past or the alacrity with which we are shutting down pubs and restaurants and nightclubs across our metros these days. The police leadership of this country, me included, loves to blame the politicians, the bureaucrats and the media for many of our failings.
But by letting loose the likes of Dhoble on an essentially law-abiding citizenry, and then hiding behind the fig leaf of the law, when truly urgent and significant policing challenges are woefully neglected, represents a criminal abdication of responsibility on part of the IPS and fools no one.
This outbreak of moral policing, totally devoid of a moral compass, in our metros is at first sight both baffling and outrageous in equal measure. But on sober reflection, it makes perfect sense. Our citizens believe with justification that these drives are simply an attempt by the police leadership to increase avenues of extortion and to divert attention from our more serious professional failings.
What we have gained in authority and forced obedience we have lost manifold in terms of trust and legitimacy. Perhaps the powers- that-be would consider replacing the P for Police in the IPS with a D for Dhoble. I am Dhoble. Indeed.
The author is a serving IPS officer. These are his personal views.
Shah Rukh Khan-Saif Ali Khan vs Aryan Khan-Ibrahim Khan: Who should be in KHNH2!
Why Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu gifted Donald Trump golden pager? It is a reference to...
Mob in Bangladesh destroys ousted PM Sheikh Hasina's family home
ISRO's EOS-06 satellite captures Phytoplankton concentration on global scale
IND vs ENG: Will Virat Kohli play in 2nd ODI vs England? Shubman Gill provides huge injury update
Who is Kiran Chaudhury? PCS officer caught in bribe case, just 4 years after posting
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah's wedding today: Know venue, gifts for guests and more
Meet woman, who works in Rs 163000 crore company, daughter of Hyderabad’s richest man
This is world's greenest railway station, 170 years old, home to over 7,000 plants, it's in....
As Sky Force nears Rs 150 crore, Nimrat Kaur treats househelp, her kids with movie screening
IND vs ENG: Shreyas Iyer creates history, becomes first player to achieve THIS massive milestone
Meet man, India's richest banker, who has bought Rs 202 crore property, his net worth is Rs...
'Heard there was....': Former India head coach provides major update on Virat Kohli's injury
A New Geopolitical Era: India and Israel's Role in the Evolving Middle East
David Warner’s touching moment with fans after Dubai Capitals reaches final of DP World ILT20
India’s Largest Book Stall Network: PrashantAdvait Foundation’s Mission to Revive Reading Culture
Mawra Hocane stuns in pastel mint green lehenga at her wedding to Ameer Gilani
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato changes its name, CEO shares journey of company, it is now called...
Rose Day 2025: Know the date, history, significance of each rose colour ahead of Valentine's day
'BJP-led NDA works for Santushtikaran, not Tushtikaran': PM Modi in Rajya Sabha
Who is Belle Gibson? Australian wellness guru created fake cancer story and later...
DP World ILT20 2025: Dubai Capitals clinch last ball thriller against Desert Vipers to reach final
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah wedding: First pic from Gautam Adani's mansion OUT as wedding festivities begin
Sunita Williams’ Spacewalk: A Record-Breaking Mission and a Stunning Selfie from Space
IND vs ENG: Ravindra Jadeja creates history in Nagpur, surpasses James Anderson to become....
Can IAS officers change cadres after marriage? Here's what rules say
Pavan Kumar Joshi innovates unemployment benefits payment security
Anil Ambani's company's share price surges over 6 per cent after it earns profit of Rs...
Why Dale Bhagwagar is Bollywood's only PR guru
Meet Anjum Khan, wife of cricket star Shivam Dube, her net worth is Rs...
IAF Mirage 2000 fighter aircraft crashes in MP's Shivpuri during training sortie
Meet IAS Tina Dabi's mother, who cleared UPSC to become IES, later resigned due to...
Good news for Infosys employees! Company to roll out annual hike letters by end of...
BIG win for India's largest govt bank, earns Rs 16891 crore profit in just...
Ajith Kumar's fans celebrate, throng theatres after Vidaamuyarchi's worldwide release: Watch
Purnam’s Spring Edit: Where heritage meets handcrafted luxury
RTPS Bihar: Apply for income, caste, and domicile certificates
'Welfare of students very close to Government's heart': EAM Jaishankar in Rajya Sabha
IND vs ENG: Why is Virat Kohli not playing 1st ODI vs England in Nagpur?
Man's love for Indian wife knows no bounds, makes dosa batter from scratch, video goes viral
Meet woman, CRPF officer, who cracked UPSC exam in first attempt, became...
Trump administration plans to pressure the IOC to come up with a uniform transgender athlete ban
PM Modi's 'Pariksha Pe Charcha' to feature Deepika Padukone, Mary Kom, Sadhguru among others
Why speed matters: Ajay Chava on overhauling CI/CD pipelines for modern development