ANALYSIS
The OECD/G20 action plan that seeks to close loopholes in tax treaties worldwide, lacks penal provisions
Using loopholes in tax laws, large corporations shift profits out of the country of operation to tax havens or Off-shore Financial Centres (OFCs) where very little of their profits were generated. These activities, collectively termed Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS), deprive countries $100-400 billion worth of corporate income tax revenues annually and affect rich and poor countries alike. This forces countries to lower their corporate tax rates in order to ensure compliance. Apart from lowering revenues to fund social sector schemes, this strategy also makes the tax structure regressive. But as long as there are OFCs and different countries have vastly different systems of taxation, MNCs will continue to use tax avoidance strategies. Countries are, therefore, trapped in an inferior equilibrium. In this equilibrium, the best response for any country is to lower its tax rates as much as possible, and we end up in a proverbial ‘race to the bottom’.
Countries would do better if they instead came together to negotiate a multilateral treaty that sets certain taxation standards, accounting principles and minimum threshold tax rates to minimise the possibility of tax avoidance. Of course, the OFCs would still exist. But if large economies ratify this treaty, then MNCs will find it difficult to avoid taxes in these countries. They also cannot shift their operations out of these countries as this is where the market is. The G20 is an ideal grouping for such a treaty. This group makes up 85 per cent of the Gross World Product (GWP).
There has indeed been a move in this direction. The OECD/G20 Action Plan on BEPS is a multilateral convention that seeks to close loopholes in tax treaties worldwide. India recently signed this convention.
However, this convention is not enough. Any signatory can decide to violate the convention by moving away from the standards enlisted in the Action Plan to attract MNCs or foreign capital into its economy. There is no penal provision for such a violation. What is needed is a stronger treaty with a ‘punishment’ clause. Thus, if any country violates the treaty, then all countries withdraw from the treaty and all of them are back to square one. In Game Theory parlance, this strategy is called Grim Trigger. The action by one country of violating the treaty triggers a set of actions that puts all of them back to the initial grim scenario.
This strategy is commonly used by unstable cartels to sustain their collusive practices.
Why should such a strategy work? As explained in the beginning itself, a world without any treaty traps all countries in an inferior equilibrium with falling revenues and regressive tax structures. A treaty improves on this outcome collectively by lowering the possibilities of tax avoidance by MNCs. Yet, a country can individually benefit by violating the terms of the treaty, given that all other countries abide by it. (Visualise the WTO treaty. Free trade benefits countries collectively. But EU benefits individually by preventing free trade in agriculture, which protects its farmers).
The author is a research scholar at Delhi School of Economics
As Sky Force nears Rs 150 crore, Nimrat Kaur treats househelp, her kids with movie screening
IND vs ENG: Shreyas Iyer creates history, becomes first player to achieve THIS massive milestone
Meet man, India's richest banker, who has bought Rs 202 crore property, his net worth is Rs...
'Heard there was....': Former India head coach provides major update on Virat Kohli's injury
A New Geopolitical Era: India and Israel's Role in the Evolving Middle East
David Warner’s touching moment with fans after Dubai Capitals reaches final of DP World ILT20
India’s Largest Book Stall Network: PrashantAdvait Foundation’s Mission to Revive Reading Culture
Mawra Hocane stuns in pastel mint green lehenga at her wedding to Ameer Gilani
Deepinder Goyal's Zomato changes its name, CEO shares journey of company, it is now called...
Rose Day 2025: Know the date, history, significance of each rose colour ahead of Valentine's day
'BJP-led NDA works for Santushtikaran, not Tushtikaran': PM Modi in Rajya Sabha
Who is Belle Gibson? Australian wellness guru created fake cancer story and later...
DP World ILT20 2025: Dubai Capitals clinch last ball thriller against Desert Vipers to reach final
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah wedding: First pic from Gautam Adani's mansion OUT as wedding festivities begin
Sunita Williams’ Spacewalk: A Record-Breaking Mission and a Stunning Selfie from Space
IND vs ENG: Ravindra Jadeja creates history in Nagpur, surpasses James Anderson to become....
Can IAS officers change cadres after marriage? Here's what rules say
Pavan Kumar Joshi innovates unemployment benefits payment security
Anil Ambani's company's share price surges over 6 per cent after it earns profit of Rs...
Why Dale Bhagwagar is Bollywood's only PR guru
Meet Anjum Khan, wife of cricket star Shivam Dube, her net worth is Rs...
IAF Mirage 2000 fighter aircraft crashes in MP's Shivpuri during training sortie
Meet IAS Tina Dabi's mother, who cleared UPSC to become IES, later resigned due to...
Good news for Infosys employees! Company to roll out annual hike letters by end of...
BIG win for India's largest govt bank, earns Rs 16891 crore profit in just...
Ajith Kumar's fans celebrate, throng theatres after Vidaamuyarchi's worldwide release: Watch
Purnam’s Spring Edit: Where heritage meets handcrafted luxury
RTPS Bihar: Apply for income, caste, and domicile certificates
'Welfare of students very close to Government's heart': EAM Jaishankar in Rajya Sabha
IND vs ENG: Why is Virat Kohli not playing 1st ODI vs England in Nagpur?
Man's love for Indian wife knows no bounds, makes dosa batter from scratch, video goes viral
Meet woman, CRPF officer, who cracked UPSC exam in first attempt, became...
Trump administration plans to pressure the IOC to come up with a uniform transgender athlete ban
PM Modi's 'Pariksha Pe Charcha' to feature Deepika Padukone, Mary Kom, Sadhguru among others
Why speed matters: Ajay Chava on overhauling CI/CD pipelines for modern development
What does "i" stands for in iPhone, iPad, and other Apple products? Check here to know
Meet Pakistani actress whose leaked private video went viral, often shares bold photos, she is..
After Isha Ambani, Ananya Birla set to enter into new space, it is...
Shah Rukh Khan hugs Aamir Khan at Loveyapa screening, fans say '90s' kids can fly now': Watch
Meet Diva Shah, daughter of diamond tycoon, she is set to marry Gautam Adani’s son Jeet Adani on...
After US, Israel halts participation in UN Human Rights Council
Sanam Teri Kasam actress Mawra Hocane ties the knot with Pakistani star Ameer Gilani, see photos
Meet woman who left MNC job to pursue her uncle’s dream, later cracked UPSC to become IPS officer
Mukesh Ambani buys India’s first bulletproof Rolls-Royce Cullinan, Its price is Rs....
Anil Ambani meets Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis as his Rs 16015 crore company is looking for...
DNA TV Show: What is US President Donald Trump's Gaza plan?
Anil Ambani's company's BIG win, reports Rs 420000000 profit in 3 months, its business is...
US President Donald Trump invites PM Modi on working visit to White House next week
Watch: Malaika Arora's 'oops moment' in short dress caught on camera, video viral
Little girl's adorable dance to 'Maula Mere Maula' captivates netizens, WATCH viral video
India beats China to become world’s second-largest market for...