ANALYSIS
Unless Dhume and his ilk take the trouble to delve into a parallel, native archive of facts, ideas, and experiences, his analysis may be doomed to be immediately off-focus and ultimately irrelevant
"Few have commented on India’s governance with such clarity & nuance,” the invitation proclaims. The speaker, Sadanand Dhume, sponsored by an international organisation, had delivered a lecture on 'How to Fix India’s Broken Secularism' on May 25 in Mumbai. Obviously, I could not attend. But if his May 4, 2017, post 'Who’s Killing India’s Secularism?' is anything to go by, his argument requires a response.
Evidently, Dhume’s admirers and promoters believe that he has something new, even significant, to contribute to the revival of Indian secularism. Though like the proverbial dead horse, no amount of flogging — or flaking — will restore it, many secularism votaries haven’t quite given up. Because its downfall, if not death, concerns us all, we must examine if Dhume’s approach adds significantly to our understanding.
Frankly, I do not think it does. My scepticism is based not on Dhume’s lack of credentials. His education is impressive, as is his subsequent career. Currently, Resident Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, he earlier served as India bureau chief of a leading Eastern newspaper. He is also the author of a political travelogue on the rise of radical Islam in Indonesia.
Dhume’s qualifications, paradoxically, signal his lack of cultural insight and training. Indeed, his educational background and subsequent achievements mark him as prime agent of what post-colonialists call ‘re-Orientalism’. From our (former) ‘white’ masters telling us who we are, we are now expected to defer to a new breed of India-born or Indian-origin experts. Most such Indian-origin foreign-trained experts serve — and are promoted by — other countries, governments, and allied agencies, even when redeployed to India. They make up an important part of the so-called ‘Lutyens’ establishment. Such an objection might be dismissed as ‘merely’ culturist or nativist.
But the fact is that from James Mill’s infamous History of British India (1817) to today’s Euro-US-centric narrative incursions, Western categories have continued to be imposed as one way of dominating and controlling us.
Dhume’s take on secularism exhibits the same discursive DNA. The title of his article uses ‘killing’ to suggest that Indian secularism isn’t dying a natural death, but is being murdered by right-wing extremists. Dhume wants to teach us how to beat these secularism-killers. Secularists should acknowledge, he argues, that “radical Islam is a problem”. As if radical Islam isn’t a huge, worldwide scourge quite on its own, Dhume suggests that Indian secularists’ denial or whitewashing of it is the reason for their decline. Now, is this really news? Has he forgotten the hoary provenance of the term pseudo-secularism, coined to expose precisely such hypocrisy?
Moreover, isn’t it puzzling, if not contradictory, that in his very first sentence Dhume flashes the minority card? “Minority rights in India are under threat,” he declaims, “Scarcely a week passes without news of an attack on Muslims by vigilantes somewhere in the country.” Dhume wanted secularists to “champion equality before the law”. If so, the violation of which special (specious?) ‘minority’ rights is he referring to? Either we support equality under the law or special rights for special interest groups. The latter being so clearly an anti-libertarian position, how can we have it both ways? Wasn’t duplicity precisely the problem with official secularism in the first place? Isn’t Dhume’s double-speak guilty of the very equivocation he censures?
Dhume next fulminates against Yogi Adityanath, UP’s Chief Minister, calling him “a rabble-rousing monk-cum-politician best known for founding a thuggish private militia and whipping up anti-Muslim emotions”. This is the first serious hint of Dhume’s cultural discomfort, if not illiteracy. Dhume can’t, despite his impeccable training, wrap his head around the Yogi phenomenon. He fails to mention that the man he accuses of being a rabble-rouser has been elected five consecutive terms to the Lok Sabha from Gorakhpur, winning with record margins. Yogi Adityanath’s experience of Indian parliamentary democracy, thus, far exceeds Dhume’s academic or armchair expertise.
The reason that Yogi baffles Dhume is that Adityanath does not fit Dhume’s categories of democracy or public life. When Dhume admits, “Reality is more complex,” it is not an admission of his own inadequacy. Far from it, he implies that he knows what’s wrong with Indian secularism while we don’t. Dhume’s inability to grasp that India might be a dharma-based society rather than modern secular State might be the real problem. No wonder, he never considers this as the primary reason for secularism’s free fall, not just the latter’s duplicity over radical Islam. ‘Dharma’ as an ontic-epistemic category doesn’t exist in Dhume’s consciousness; naturally, the word, let alone the idea, is totally absent in his analysis. Who will explain to Dhume that there is no magic bullet to ‘fix’ Indian secularism? There is no simple way to move from our deep-seated civilizational mismatch with secularism to the unproblematic equality that Dhume advocates.
India shows us over and over again that it is not entirely amenable to foreign-returned ‘expertise’. Training in the Western academy, at best, teaches us how to use rational tools and accumulated knowledge, but it does not equip us with cultural inwardness, let alone profound civilizational knowledge. The result? Famous echo-chamber experts who reveal more about themselves than the complex country they claim to analyse. Unless Dhume and his ilk take the trouble to delve into a parallel, native archive of facts, ideas, and experiences, his analysis may be doomed to be immediately off-focus and ultimately irrelevant.
The author is a poet and Professor at JNU
Meet Gyanesh Kumar, IIT graduate, who becomes new Chief Election Commissioner
DNA TV Show: RSS' Bihar model ahead of Assembly elections in state
WPL 2025: Renuka, Wareham spark collapse as RCB bowl out Delhi Capitals for 141
Champions Trophy 2025: Ex-Pak cricketer says Pakistan don't deserve to win, 'Chal jaaye toh...'
Samantha Ruth Prabhu's Dippam Dappam dance leaves Chennai students awestruck, viral video
Breaking MS Dhoni's record is no big deal for Dinesh Karthik: 'It’s not something...'
Amid Mahakumbh rush, video of vehicle running on railway track goes viral; here's why
Who is Rohit Chopra? Indian-origin businessman called arrogant by JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon
All eyes on Mohammed bin Salman, as Trump, Putin and Zelensky set to meet in Saudi Arabia for...
WATCH: BJP office bearer dances to ‘Main Hoon Don’ flashing gun, FIR filed
Nepal student death: Massive protests at Odisha's KIIT University, students demand justice
Meet man, son of famous film actor, cracked UPSC exam with full-time job, his AIR was…
Mahakumbh 2025: Fire breaks out again at Prayagraj, no casualties reported
Gautam Adani, India's second richest man, donates Rs 2000 crore for setting up 20...
‘I am not a...’: Jaya Kishori BREAKS silence on her Rs 2.6 lakh Dior bag controversy, WATCH here
Dil Madharasi Teaser: Sivakarthikeyan impresses in rugged avatar, to face off against Vidyut Jammwal
PCB breaks silence on no Indian flags in Pakistani stadiums ahead of Champions Trophy 2025
Delhi residents report hearing mysterious ‘boom’ sound during earthquake; what caused it?
After Narayana Murthy's Infosys, Ratan Tata’s TCS makes BIG announcement, set to issue...
JPMorgan Chase CEO rejects hybrid work requests from employees amid layoffs says, ‘Don’t waste...'
Auspicious Start for 'Jatadhara': Mahurat ceremony held in Hyderabad
Kirill Yurovskiy: How to Build a Sustainable Fashion Brand in the UK
Bad news for Jhunjhunwala as the company loses Rs..., stock goes down by...
Audi launches Audi RS Q8 2025 in India: Know price, specifications and unique features
The Power of Ayurveda: Dr Shyam's Ayurveda Leads the Wellness Revolution in Dubai
15 Crucial Factors to Consider Before Choosing MBBS in Georgia 2025: Education Vibes
Narayana Dominates JEE Main 2025 Session 1 with Exceptional Results
Karan Johar says Yash Johar was 'heartbroken' when Amitabh Bachchan's... flopped: 'He believed...'
Meet Acharya Indravarman: The best astrologer in Bengaluru & Karnataka
How to increase your chances of getting a personal loan
After retaining Asia's richest family tag, now Mukesh Ambani's Reliance beats Apple to become...
Ex-star cricketer, wife buy luxury apartment for Rs 110000000, it is located in...
How a name change caused makers of Bira beer to lose hundreds of crores; know what happened
The Power of Networking: How IFERP memberships open doors to global opportunities for universities
India's Got Latent row: Maharashtra Cyber Cell refuses Samay Raina's special request to...
Mukesh Ambani's wife Nita Ambani makes passionate pitch for Olympics 2036, says 'India will...'
Jyotiraditya Scindia makes BIG announcement on 6G, claims internet speed will be...
Meet man, who was once member of MS Dhoni-led Chennai Super Kings, now works as a bus driver
Did Virat Kohli get special food delivery amid BCCI's 'no personal chef' rule? Report claims...
Gautam Adani's BIG move in space sector, Adani-backed firm among three finalists in India's...
New India Co-op Bank: RBI uncovers massive fraud of Rs 122 crore; know what’s the case
Shakira hospitalised due to abdominal pain, apologises to fans for cancelling Peru concert
South Korean actress Kim Sae-ron of A Brand New Life fame found dead at 24
'Life-threatening cold' ALERT in US as Polar Vortex, snow, floods grip America: What does that mean?
Cristiano Ronaldo vs Lionel Messi, who is better? 66 per cent of former footballers believe...
Champions Trophy 2025: No Indian flag in Lahore Stadium sparks controversy ahead of tournament
After strong tremors in Delhi-NCR, 4.0 magnitude earthquake jolts Bihar's Siwan
Delhi-NCR earthquake: Netizens react with hilarious memes amid 4.0 magnitude tremors, check here
BAFTA: Payal Kapdia's All We Imagine As Light faces another disappointment, films loses to...
Student paraglides to college after getting late for exam, netizens react, watch viral video
Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu issues BIG warning to Hamas: 'Gates of hell will...'
Delhi-NCR Earthquake Today: Tremors of magnitude 4 jolt Delhi and adjoining areas
This film has broken world box office records, not Hollywood, Bollywood but...
Meet Satyam Pandey who got high-paying job offer, not from IIM, NIT, IIIT, his annual salary is…
Gurgaon couple reunites with lost dog after three-month search in Agra
Meet man, IIT graduate, who topped UPSC exam in third attempt, he is from...
Noida authority takes BIG action against promoters of 2 housing projects, as realty firm fails to...
WPL 2025: Ashleigh Gardner, Deandra Dottin star as Gujarat Giants beat UP Warriorz by 6 wickets