ANALYSIS
The public hearing is a legal requirement under the approval procedures for the expansion of an existing coal mine
For the people of Sundargarh in Odisha, the New Year had a different ring. They were preparing to participate in an environmental public hearing organised by the government. The public hearing is a legal requirement under the approval procedures for the expansion of an existing coal mine. A small group of people, already affected by the ongoing mine operations, spent months prior to the hearing, doing detailed surveys and collecting visible evidence of non-compliance of safeguards listed in the operational mine’s approval letter. At the hearing on January 10, they presented their findings in the form of a report. It is a carefully assembled dossier of violations that have caused dust pollution, water contamination and fires in the mine’s overburden dumps and have made life for the people around the mine a nightmare. Their presentation makes it clear that not only are these actions harming them, but the mine operations are unlawful.
Taking environmental non-compliance seriously: Compliance has come a long way in the system of environmental regulation. It used to be an issue tucked away at the very end of laws that grant approvals to projects, their use of water, forests and other natural resources. Today, the state of environmental compliance of government-approved high investment projects has gained attention of the public, the judiciary and institutions such as the CAG. Statistics generated by these sources reveal high levels of non-compliance and their staggering implications on communities living around these projects as well as the environment as a whole. Under pressure, successive governments have taken slow and awkward steps towards amending this situation. After all, without compliance to legal provisions, development can be rendered an illegal process. Also, any efforts to intensity development through project expansions or approving new projects could be met with total opposition and endless litigation.
In 2012, the Environment Ministry issued a circular stating that data on compliance be included for appraisal by expert committees who review approval proposals for project expansion. However, this did not have any positive effect on the approvals because the data arrived too late in the process of decision-making.
In September 2017, the ministry made it mandatory for compliance reports to be scrutinised well in advance, that is, prior to the issuing of a Terms of Reference for conducting Environment Impact Assessments (EIA). This process is now meant to act as a filter against violating projects.
Need for meaningful data through monitoring: While the attention to compliance in the approval-granting procedures is a necessary first step, it can hardly achieve good results on its own. A big issue in the compliance enforcement system is the government’s near-total inability to be everywhere these projects are and gather meaningful data on the ongoing performance of projects. When the ministry’s expert committee reviewed a coal mining expansion project in Chhattisgarh in January 2017, the government’s monitoring reports had no data on non-compliance. As in the case of the project in Odisha, it was the evidence collected by affected people and researchers that showed the accurate picture. This relevant information made it possible to stay the expansion till the illegalities are addressed.
Since 2009 several studies have established that environmental regulatory institutions are simply incapable of monitoring the over 15000 centrally-approved projects. The Pollution Control Boards or the Groundwater Authority have been open about their lack of capacity to undertake checks as well as political interference in their work. On the other hand, the fear of the return of the corrupt “inspector raj” looms over project developers. The “third party”, or the affected communities who experience the effects of non-compliance such as loss of livelihoods, poor living conditions and displacement are nowhere in the picture when monitoring is done. This means that though we may have finally designed a new system of compliance-based approvals, we have no creative ways to monitor and gather useful data on the compliance of projects.
Models of engagement: To overcome this massive problem and effectively improve the levels of compliance by operating projects, environmental institutions must adopt the public, especially affected people, as partners in regulation. They can no longer be considered ignorant, prejudiced or an adversary. The field of environmental monitoring and compliance can benefit a lot from models of participation to plan and conduct joint site visits, to acknowledge and use the data generated by affected people through community research projects. We would all benefit from annual public environmental audits of projects, much like the successful social audits of government schemes. These steps will help to generate meaningful data for use by the environmental regulators. They also give affected communities a real chance at shaping developmental outcomes and their neighbourhoods.
The authors are with the CPR-Namati Environment Justice Program
Asense Interior: Celebrating 11 Years of Redefining Luxury Interiors in Bengaluru
Kiss Day 2025: Why do we celebrate this day? Know history and significance
DNA Verified: Is Rashtrapati Bhavan hosting a wedding for the FIRST time? Know truth here
India's retail inflation slows to 4.31 per cent in January due to...
WATCH: Maha Kumbh girl Mona Lisa starts training before filming her 1st movie alongside Anupam Kher
Radhika Merchant stuns in blue and green suit at MahaKumbh Mela, it costs Rs....
BIG move by Mukesh Ambani, Reliance partners with US company, set to drive...
IND v ENG: Why are India and England players wearing green arm bands in 3rd ODI at Ahmedabad?
Tripti Dimri sets major beachwear goals in Maldives; can you guess price of her swimsuit?
Mitolyn Supplement Reviews: Ingredients, benefits, side effects, purple peel exploit
Gaurav Sharma: Visionary leader driving cybersecurity excellence
All About Details: Turning ordinary outfits into statement looks
Duolingo owl is dead? Launguage learning app urges users to respect Dua Lipa's privacy, know why
Why digitisation is necessary in construction industry and why its adoption remains slow
Meet IIT-JEE topper, who created record in Odisha by scoring 99.98 percentile, aims to join...
When is Shab-e-Barat 2025 – February 13 or 14? Check history, significance
THIS is India's last railway station where train never stops, know why
GBS outbreak: Mumbai reports its first death due to Guillain-Barre Syndrome
Ram Gopal Varma questions Rajinikanth's acting, says 'I don’t know if he can exist without...'
Who was Acharya Satyendra Das? Ayodhya Ram temple's chief priest who passed away in Lucknow
Old wedding card mentioning IIT degrees of couple creates buzz on social media; see viral post
Chunky Panday says Shatrughan Sinha advised him to 'make people wait': 'If you are punctual...'
UP Court summons Rahul Gandhi on March 24 over 2022 remarks against Army
Indian consulate in Marseille to strengthen 'people-to-people ties': PM Modi
India’s Top 5 Richest YouTubers: Know who’s earning more than Samay Raina and Ranveer Allahbadia?
Mukesh Ambani, Sunil Mittal are working to revolutionise mobile calling in India by...
DNA TV Show: UP CM Yogi Adityanath's multi-level plan for Maghi Purnima
Tejasswi Prakash reveals why she joined Celebrity MasterChef: 'I am obsessed with...'
Delhi-NCR schools holiday: Delhi, Noida, Gurugram, Ghaziabad, schools closed tomorrow due to...
'We can teach children AI but...': Sudha Murty urges govt to provide funds to schools to promote...
THIS startup gives whopping bonus to employees for loyalty, they get Rs...
JEE Main 2025 Toppers List Released: Meet 14 candidates who scored 100 percentile this year
JEE Main Result 2025 DECLARED: Get direct link, steps to check NTA score and other details HERE
SHOCKING! Noida family held under ‘digital arrest’ for 5 days, loses Rs 1 crore to cyber fraud
Ranveer Singh, Akshaye Khanna shoot for Aditya Dhar's Dhurandhar in Mumbai, pictures get leaked
Why are hobby classes integral to Podar International School’s curriculum in Khopoli?
Mukesh Ambani buys Rs 6437604000 stake in THIS cricket team, not Mumbai Indians
World's richest man Elon Musk loses Rs 789330000000 in four days, net worth slips below Rs...
'Need global standards': PM Modi pushes for AI governance at Paris AI Summit
Ashutosh Rana slams Prabhas, Saif Ali Khan-starrer Adipurush: 'Audiences will not accept...'
Ahead of PM Modi-Donald Trump meet, India considers cutting tariffs on THESE items imported from US
Communication platforms are fast evolving into super apps
Mumbai Police reaches Ranveer Allahbadia's home in connection to India's Got Latent controversy
Junaid Khan says Aamir Khan, Reena Dutta spent ‘ridongculous’ amount on his...
Rohit Sharma, Rishabh Pant's warm gesture towards kid wins internet, watch viral video
Ajith Kumar recalls 'bad crash’ ahead of Portugal race: ‘When I crashed...'
India's Got Latent episode feat Ranveer Allahbadia blocked after government orders
Samay Raina performs in Seattle, enjoys with friends amid Ranveer Allahbadia controversy
Good news for Gautam Adani as Adani stocks rally up to 4.5% due to Donald Trump's this BIG move...
Amid rumours of dissent, AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal holds meeting with Punjab CM Mann, MLAs in Delhi