ANALYSIS
Directions on police reforms have been ignored 12 years after they were given by the apex court
The Bulandshahr incident in which gaurakshaks were emboldened to kill a police inspector was the latest in a series of incidents that have exposed the fragile law and order situation in several parts of the country, primarily due to law enforcement agencies trying to be on the right side of politicians in power.
The executive wants to maintain the status quo to ensure its hegemony over the police and has therefore been stalling every effort to give even minimum operational autonomy to the police.
It is a sad commentary on our state governments’ commitment to rule of law that directions given by the highest court of the land are not being implemented in letter and spirit even after a lapse of 12 years.
The Supreme Court had given six directions to the state governments and one to the central government. These are aimed at insulating the police from external pressures, giving them a fair measure of autonomy in personnel matters, and ensuring that complaints of serious misconduct against the police are effectively acted upon.
The court also prescribed a procedure for the appointment of Director General of Police and laid down that, once appointed, he shall have a minimum tenure of two years.
Security of tenure was also assured to officers on operational assignments. It was further stated that the investigation of crime and maintenance of law and order should be separated to improve the quality of investigations.
A total of 17 states have so far passed Police Acts ostensibly in compliance of the court’s directions, but in reality, these are attempts to circumvent their implementation by taking advantage of the fact that the court’s guidelines were to be “operative till the new legislation is enacted by state governments.”
Institutions mandated by the Supreme Court – State Security Commission, Police Establishment Board, Police Complaints Authority – have been set up, but their charter has been diluted, powers curtailed and composition subverted.
There is arbitrariness in the appointment of DGPs while police officers on operational duties are transferred for all kinds of administrative reasons before the completion of two years.
There is tardiness in the separation of investigative and law and order functions of the police. The remaining states have passed executive orders, which are also not in keeping with the letter and spirit of court’s directions.
Justice Thomas Committee, which was appointed by the Supreme Court to examine the compliance of its directions, expressed its “dismay over the total indifference to the issue of reforms in the functioning of police being exhibited by the states”.
A number of petitions were filed for issuance of contempt notices to the state governments. On April 23, 2007, on the basis of information then available, the court was asked to initiate contempt proceedings against six states, namely Jammu and Kashmir, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh.
In due course, contempt petitions were also filed against the government of Maharashtra in 2013, and against the government of UP in 2015. The court, for inexplicable reasons, has not entertained any of these contempt petitions so far. No wonder, the states continue to flout judicial directions.
The Central government has also not shown commitment to police reforms. Soli Sorabjee had prepared a Model Police Act in 2006, and it was expected that the MHA would legislate a Police Act on those lines. However, that has not been done so far.
What is worse, the Central government tried to subvert one of the Supreme Court’s directions on police reforms by issuing Indian Police Service (Cadre) Amendment Rules, 2014, whereby a Civil Services Board was constituted to make recommendations for appointment of all cadre officers.
The composition of the Board was in complete violation of the direction issued by the court in police reforms case regarding setting up of a Police Establishment Board. The IPS (Cadre) Amendment Rules, 2014, were challenged and, fortunately, the Supreme Court has stayed their operation.
The government of India is, very unfortunately, even trying to get the court’s 2006 directions diluted. It has been successful to an extent in that, due to the pressure mounted by it. The Supreme Court on July 3, 2018, issued a slew of directions, which amount to diluting the original 2006 mandate of the court regarding the tenure of DGP.
The original 2006 order mentioned that the Director General of Police shall have “a minimum tenure of at least two years irrespective of his date of superannuation”. On July 3, however, the court said that the DGP’s “extended term beyond the date of superannuation should be a reasonable period”. This “reasonable period” may be interpreted differently by state governments and would create avoidable confusion.
So, where do we go from here? Would the police reforms agenda be pushed forward and carried to its logical conclusion or would the stalemate continue? Or, if worse, would there be a regressive movement?
There can be no healthy democracy unless police is insulated from outside pressures. Economic progress can only be sustained on the foundations of good law and order. The future of India is linked to the progress in police reforms.
The questions bothering the common man are: why are state governments not complying with the Supreme Court’s directions? Why are they not hauled over the coals? Why is the majesty of law not upheld?
Author is a police reform campaigner
Meet woman, who plays key role in Rs 33661 crore company, daughter of billionaire
Vicky Kaushal and Akshaye Khanna didn't talk to each other on the Chhaava sets because...
Nita Ambani, Nick Jonas share candid moments at Siddharth Chopra's wedding, WATCH viral video
UPSC Civil Services Prelims Exam 2025 registration date extended by 7 days; apply at upsc.gov.in
'Fight for progress of Delhi will continue', says LoP Rahul Gandhi after Congress's Delhi debacle
Namma Metro Fare Update: Travel rides get costlier by 50 per cent from THIS date; check details
'AAP-Da Mukt Delhi': PM Modi hails BJP's resounding victory in assembly polls 2025
'He is fit to...': India batting coach shares BIG update on Virat Kohli ahead of IND vs ENG 2nd ODI
IND vs ENG: Rohit Sharma on cusp of breaking Sachin Tendulkar's record in elite openers list
NASA confirms Sunita Williams' return date, denies US President Trump’s ‘stranded’ claim
Meet man whose airline went bankrupt, still has Rs 43894 crore net worth, he is...
Ranji Trophy: Suryakumar Yadav's horror show with bat continues, India star clean bowled for just...
Chocolate Day 2025: 5 easy homemade chocolate recipes to impress your partner
Mass layoffs at Infosys as company terminates 700 freshers over...
Priyanka Chopra wears 62-emerald bead Bvlgari necklace at her brother's wedding
Chocolate Day 2025: Date, significance, history and celebration ideas
Meet Swati Singh, wife of BJP's Parvesh Verma, who defeated Arvind Kejriwal by 4089 votes
Meet man, son of world’s richest woman, he is set to take over Rs 1642000 crore empire as...
SHOCKING! Bride's family cancels wedding at last moment over groom's low...
Nita Ambani, Shloka Mehta stun in gorgeous sarees at Priyanka Chopra's brother's wedding
Meet Trisha and Sanidhi, daughters of BJP's Parvesh Verma, who defeated Arvind Kejriwal
New entrant in grocery quick-commerce, ready to compete with industry giants
Transforming the news and media industry with Generative AI: Expert insights by Sanjay Jain
Dr Tanvi Tijoriwala, ND shedsputs light on balancing skin barrier during rising temperatures
How PM Modi's magic shattered Arvind Kejriwal and his third-term hope in Delhi?
Ahmedabad: Fire breaks out at Sabarmati bullet train station, check details
Meet Sunita Kejriwal, Arvind Kejriwals's wife, who was former IRS officer, met him during...
BIG blow for Meta employees, Mark Zuckerberg's company to layoff employees from..., reason is...
Amitabh Bachchan sparks major concern among fans with cryptic post, writes 'time to go'
Taylor Swift 'feels used' by Blake Lively, wishes she didn't drag her into Justin Baldoni case
Meet IAS officer who failed five times before cracking UPSC exam, cleared in 6th attempt with AIR...
Delhi Election Result 2025 Live Updates: Check full list of winners and losers in Delhi elections
Who is Kabir Bahia, Kriti Sanon's rumoured boyfriend who hid his face from paps
Delhi Election Result 2025: AAP's Arvind Kejriwal vs BJP's Parvesh Verma; key contests to watch out
Bank holidays in February 2025: Check if banks are open or closed on February 8?
Cristiano Ronaldo sends heartfelt retirement message to former Real Madrid teammate Marcelo Viera
Jeet Adani, Diva Shah are now married! Here's why their wedding was more than a mere celebration
IIT-BHU student gets highest package of Rs..., average package in 2025 is...
Music composer Anu Malik sells two Mumbai flats in Santacruz West for Rs..., co-owner is...
Jeet Adani and Diva Shah are now married; video of varmala ceremony goes viral, WATCH
Jeet Adani-Diva Shah wedding: Gautam Adani shares first pics of son's wedding, see here