ANALYSIS
An Arab Spring, a European freeze and a changing climate — Gwynne Dyer asks whether the world can weather these storms.
Every year brings changes, but some years really are turning points: 1492, 1789, 1914, and 1989, for example. Does 2011 belong in the august company of such Really Important Years? Probably not, but it definitely qualifies for membership in the second tier of Quite Important Years.
Three big stories ran right through the year, any one of which would have qualified 2011 for membership status. The Arab Spring is an epochal event, even if democratic revolutions may fail in some countries in the end. The euro crisis threatens the European Union with collapse and confirms the shift of economic power from West to East. And the struggle to prevent disastrous climate change was abandoned for the rest of the decade.
The name, it should be noted, is the Arab Spring, not the Muslim Spring, because a majority of the world’s Muslims already live in countries that are democratic: Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Bangladesh, Pakistan, and even Iran (in roughly descending order of how democratic they really are). But the Arab countries seemed remarkably impervious to democracy — until it suddenly became clear that they weren’t. The revolutions in Tunisia, Egypt and Libya were not just about elections. They were revolts against the arrogance and corruption of the ruling elites, against poverty, against the reign of fear that underpinned all of those regimes. But there was and still is a genuine democratic idealism at the heart of these revolutions, and despite all the disappointments and detours that will inevitably follow, something profound has changed in the Arab world.
Similar revolutions could well succeed to other Arab countries in the coming year, but in some cases they may not even be necessary. Formerly autocratic monarchies like Jordan and Morocco are in full retreat, hoping to safeguard their privileges by granting political freedoms to the people. And the long and increasingly bloody struggle in Syria could still end in a relatively peaceful transition to democracy, not a civil war.
We should have learned not to underestimate people by now. The ruthless Burmese regime is retreating from power under relentless pressure from the pro-democracy movement led by Aung San Suu Kyi, and even Vladimir Putin in Moscow must suddenly feel vulnerable as he watches the crowds come out in Russia to demand their country back. Non-violence works. It will even work in China eventually.
From the sublime to the ridiculous. The decade-old euro, which aspired to become the common currency of the European Union and even a rival to the US dollar, is in acute danger of collapse, and the efforts of European leaders to save it have been comically inept.
Seventeen of the 27 countries in the EU, including all the big economies except Britain’s, use the euro, but that number may drop sharply in the next few years. It might even drop to zero.
The euro was a political project from the start, and it may also die of politics. The initial idea was that a common currency would bind the EU members closer together, but it never made any sense for low-productivity economies like Spain, Italy and Greece to use the same currency as high-performing economies like Germany.
The only way it could have worked was for the richer countries to subsidise the poorer countries forever (like the richer regions of France or Japan subsidise the poorer regions). Then, provided that there was also a powerful central bank to stop the poorer countries from borrowing too much (because they now had a strong currency, which let them borrow almost unlimited amounts of money at very low rates), the whole project might work.
The richer countries like Germany and France had no intention of subsidising the poorer ones, and they wouldn’t allow a powerful central bank either, but the project went ahead anyway. The euro might have stumbled on, amid growing difficulties, for another decade — but the international financial crisis of 2008 put an end to that.
When the tide goes out, as legendary investor Warren Buffett put it, you find out who’s been swimming naked. The European economies were as naked as jaybirds, and so the vultures began to circle (to mix a metaphor). Every month of this year has seen another “crisis summit” meeting of EU leaders, but they have produced no credible solution to the euro’s problems because the richer countries are still unwilling to subsidise the poorer ones.
There are three possible outcomes to this mess. One is that the poorer countries simply bail out of the euro and revive their old separate currencies, which would cause some serious bank crashes in Europe and collateral damage elsewhere.
The second is that the euro as a whole collapses, causing severe damage to all the Western economies including the United States. The third is that the European Union itself falls apart.
Option one is almost certain to happen. Option two is getting more likely by the month. Option three is still relatively unlikely — which is just as well, given what a disunited Europe used to be like. But the sheer vulnerability of what are still technically the world’s most powerful economies is now plain for all to see.
The power shift from the old Atlantic world to the emerging economies of Asia was going to happen eventually in any case: the five centuries when the Europeans and their overseas kin were global top dogs are at an end. But the arrogant risk-taking, blind greed, and sheer ignorance that caused the crash of 2008 and its after-shocks are making the shift happen a lot faster.
And so to the really bad news. The Arctic sea ice is disappearing faster than even the pessimists feared, massive floods are devastating huge areas (Pakistan, Thailand, Australia), and sea level is rising at twice the predicted speed, but nothing will be done about it for the next ten years. That, effectively, was the decision — or rather, the non-decision — taken at the annual climate change summit in Durban in December.
It has been clear since the debacle at Copenhagen in 2009 that a global agreement to curb the warming was in grave trouble, but the deal in Durban may have been worse than no deal at all. The only existing agreement, the Kyoto Protocol of fifteen years ago, has been extended for another five years, but it only limits the emissions of the developed countries, and even they will not be required to meet any stricter targets than those they accepted in 1997. The emerging economies, whose emissions are growing very fast, still face no restrictions at all, although China is already the world’s biggest emitter of greenhouse gases. The target date agreed for a new, more ambitious global agreement is now 2015, but they won’t even start talking about that until 2013. And even if they do make a new deal by 2015, which is far from certain, they have already agreed that it will not go into effect until 2020.
It is not the first time that short-term self-interest has triumphed over the long-term common interest, but it may be the worst time. By 2020 it will probably be impossible to prevent the rise in average global temperature from exceeding 2 degrees C (3.6 degrees F), which is generally agreed to be the point of no return. After that, we will probably find ourselves in a new world of runaway warming. We know it, and yet we do nothing.
Oh, and the world’s population reached the seven billion mark in 2011. It passed through one billion around 1800, and was still only 2 billion in 1940. Enough said.
The author is a London-based independent journalist whose articles are published in 45 countries
WhatsApp, Instagram, Facebook down for several users globally, Meta says...
DNA TV Show: Why AAP ruled out alliance with Congress for Delhi Assembly elections
ZIM vs AFG, 1st T20I: Zimbabwe stun Afghanistan by 4 wickets in last ball thriller, lead series 1-0
Lok Sabha passes Railways Amendment Bill 2024, minister Ashiwni Vaishnaw says won't lead to...
IND vs AUS: Key milestones await Jasprit Bumrah, Rishabh Pant in Brisbane Test against Australia
'Cutest’: Bride’s sisters’ beautiful dance for their ‘Jiju’ goes viral, WATCH viral video
Meet son of India's 3rd richest woman, who studied in US, now leads Rs 110000 crore company as...
Mohammed Shami makes history in Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy, achieves rare treble in....
Thailand announces e-visa for Indians from THIS date; check details here
BIG win for Anil Ambani, his company bags India's single largest...
Missed filing ITR in July? Check last date to file tax returns or get penalised for Rs....
Kangana Ranaut reacts to Bengaluru techie suicide case: 'Men who are at fault...'; gets trolled
BGT: Gabba pitch curator provides major insights on wicket ahead of 3rd India vs Australia Test
'Good kisser': Uber driver receives bizarre feedback from customer, watch viral post here
CAT 2024 Results: Know expected date, time, cut-offs, steps to check and more
FlowForce Max Review [Official 2025]: Is Flow Force Max Prostate scam or legit?
Gautam Adani DROPS Rs 46907229600 US loan deal for Sri Lanka terminal, to use...
Centre urges states to make THIS disease notifiable due to..., know here
Viral Video: Mother busy making reel, brother saves sister's life on roadside, watch here
Watch: Furious customer rams car into showroom over refund dispute, video goes viral
Chhattisgarh: Naxalite killed in encounter, 2 security personnel injured in IED blast
Bengaluru techie suicide: Police file FIR, say wife, her family harassed him
Is Malaika Arora dating Rahul Vijay after breakup with Arjun Kapoor? Truth revealed
After Atul Subhash's suicide, internet demands Accenture to fire his wife
Mohan Babu booked for attacking journalist on camera during family feud
THIS traditional food from Tripura has anti-obesity properties, check this study
Saira Banu shares major health update after being diagnosed with pneumonia: 'I have...'
Shah Rukh Khan, Gauri Khan look to revamp luxurious Mumbai home Mannat, seek permission to add…
Why did Deepika Padukone want to see Katrina Kaif's passport? Reddit user decodes
Reimagining brand narratives beyond visual boundaries
Delhi Assembly Polls: AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal rules out possibility of alliance with Congress
Bigg Boss 18’s Avinash Mishra, Rajat Dalal get into heated argument: ‘Kal idhar se koi bhi…’
Shillong Teer Results TODAY December 11, 2024 Live Updates: Check winning numbers here
BTS' Jin says he is not friends with V, RM, Jimin, Jungkook, J-Hope, Suga: 'Sometimes you won't...'
Bank Holiday December 2024: Are banks open or closed on December 11 in THIS state?
Renowned poet Nikki Giovanni dies at 81
Meet girl who earned two engineering degrees at 11, has IQ higher than Albert Einstein, she is...
Meet richest Indian in energy sector, who leads Rs 57789 crore company, his net worth is Rs...
Meet woman, who fought depression, bounced back to crack UPSC exam, became IAS officer with AIR...
Elon Musk reacts to his old video from 1998 on future of internet: 'They thought I was...'
Meet son of Indian billionaire, who leads Rs 21430 crore company, Amitabh Bachchan is his...
IND-W vs AUS-W, 3rd ODI: Predicted playing XIs, live streaming details, weather and pitch report
'I am uncomfortable...': Ajith Kumar REACTS to Kadavule Ajithey slogans, says 'live and let live'
Watch: Virat Kohli, Rohit Sharma hit the nets ahead of Brisbane Test vs Australia
Actor Mushtaq Khan kidnapped from Delhi-Meerut Highway, held hostage for 12 hours
This is India's most searched person in 2024, it's not Virat Kohli, Mukesh Ambani, Dhoni, SRK
HTS's Man in Damascus: al-Bashir's Rise and the Future of Syria