Twitter
Advertisement

Maharashtra Aids project indicted for fraud

The World Bank has sharply criticised the implementation of India’s NACP-2 for high levels of corruption, misappropriation and financial irregularities.

Latest News
article-main
FacebookTwitterWhatsappLinkedin

World Bank review shows that a big chunk of the NACP-2 funds went for bribes, faulty kits led to wrong diagnosis

NEW DELHI: The World Bank has sharply criticised the implementation of India’s Second National Aids Control Project (NACP-2) for high levels of corruption, misappropriation and financial irregularities. Mumbai and Maharashtra share the lion’s share of the blame for the fraud and mismanagement in NACP-2, which ran from September 1999 to March 2006.

The bank’s detailed implementation review (DIR) suggests that bribes of 10-40% had to be paid by non-governmental organisations (NGOs) for the release of funds, NGOs were poorly monitored and some were non-existent, and, worse, the poor quality of testing kits supplied may have exaggerated the number of people testing HIV-positive.

Faulty kits showed people as HIV-positive when they were not, ruining people’s lives and forcing them to live with stigma and psychological stress when they had no need to. The bank’s review found that a large number of false HIV/Aids- positive cases were detected due to faulty diagnostic kits supplied by Monozyme India Ltd, Span Diagnostics Ltd and Zhongshan Biotech Company Ltd of China.

Interestingly, despite having problems in their contracts, the Maharashtra State Aids Control Society (MSACS) and the Mumbai District Aids Control Society (MDACS) continued to award contracts to these companies even when there were 21 other companies who could have supplied the same kits.

These contracts were awarded without checking the authenticity, credentials and credibility of the suppliers. In one case, the review team found Chinese restaurant Golden Dragon at the address given by Zhongshan’s local distributor in Mumbai, Spectra Pharma and Health Products.

While the review has raised questions about the legitimacy of the supplier, the report also hints at the connivance of MDACS officials who did not even bother to verify the credentials of the supplier before awarding such an important contract.

The World Bank noted several indicators of fraud and corruption in procurement procedures for testing kits, including long delays in opening bids and awarding contracts, apparent avoidance of the World Bank’s prior review threshold and unusual pricing patterns.

What followed was a disaster for many patients. Summarising the results of cross-checking HIV test results at Mumbai’s KEM Hospital VCTC, the World Bank found that more than half the number of people declared HIV positive using Monozyme kits (2,640 out of 4,620) actually tested negative when rescreened. In fact, only 1,980 finally tested positive after two supplementary screenings. In other words, from the original list of 19,331 people tested, the faulty tests showed 23.9% as HIV-positive when the real figure should have been 10.49%. A huge 13.66% of people were wrongly declared as HIV-positive when they were in sound health.

At GT Hospital, 28 out of the 4,920 people tested with Monozyme kits showed a false positive. At JJ Hospital, 17 out of 873 results were discordant. The overall discordance rate at JJ Hospital was 12.23%. These and several other hospitals in Maharashtra had complained about the faulty testing kits, indicating the extent of the problem.
 
The substandard quality of test kits used yielded invalid and unusually high false positive results, or discordant results. Some test kits were distributed near their expiry dates. At blood banks, false negative results carry the risk of infected blood being given through transfusions; a false positive test means blood that can be used for those who need it is actually wasted.

All this continued despite regular complaints from blood banks like Indian Red Cross Society and Tata Memorial Hospital in Mumbai, and Rajawadi Hospital. MDACS actually reported the matter to the National Aids Control Organisation (Naco) in 2006 only after the latter’s pressure for a feedback.

Find your daily dose of news & explainers in your WhatsApp. Stay updated, Stay informed-  Follow DNA on WhatsApp.
Advertisement

Live tv

Advertisement
Advertisement