Home > Lifestyle > Report

The expat in the newsroom

Mayank Tewari / DNA
Sunday, October 18, 2009 2:42 IST
Email Email
Print Print
Share Share

These days everybody in Delhi loves an expat. But there was a time, a decade or so ago, when Delhi wasn't the global destination and white women in the diplomatic enclave did not leave their house lest they got some tropical disease.

Those days the internet was called the information superhighway and Delhi was still waiting for its first big mall and first big multiplex. Justine Hardy's Scoopwallah was written during the 1990s, when she came to India and, following the footsteps of Rudyard Kipling (who reported for Lucknow-based The Pioneer) joined the features bureau of the Indian Express.

The book, published now after a gap of a decade, has all the usual suspects. Justine's Delhi has cows on the road with darting autos and belching taxis; friendly autorickshaw-drivers and erstwhile princes; middle-aged women trying to get their daughters married, and more middle-aged women looking for solace in the ashrams of middle-aged god men.

The people Justine talks about come across as caricatures of themselves -- not for lack of clarity in storytelling but mainly on account of the tomes already published by expats on the pains, joys and slums surrounding their Indian experience.

Thankfully, for Justine, most of these accounts have spared the newsroom in their third world contextualisation of India. Her depiction of the life and times of a bustling Delhi daily in the late 1990s is full of journalists coming to grips with a changing news scenario.

She overcomes her initial shock at her editor's disregard for hard politics and burning social issues and does what she's asked to do: stories that talk of the emerging new affluent India where fashion designers and socialites have a demi-god status.

She does her job but is still confused. At the height of election fever in the city, her editor is more interested in fashion shows and film premiers. She also has trouble understanding why her boss would like her to write a 'fun' piece on the tea gardens in Assam when she would rather report on the insurgency eating up the state.

The temptation to define and correctly analyse a third world country in the throes of a social transformation is often too much for an expat journo. Thankfully, the author doesn't probe too deep for the answers. That's probably why there is as much of Justine Hardy in the book as there is of Delhi and the characters it offers.

Copyright permission mandatory to republish this article.
For reprint rights click here
digg reddit google Facebook MySpace delicious

Post your comment

Readers' comments:
What a sour and unfair review of a book I read with much pleasure when it first came out some ten years ago. It's telling that Mayank Tewari doesn't even know it is a reissue.
Sunday, October 18, 2009 16:06 IST
Bakhti, Bombay
One of the things that Hardy doesn't mention in her book is the old stereotype of Indian journalists as lazy, glib, opinionated without effort, ever resentful with a special chip on the shoulder about foreigners who dare to write anything about India (it's ok for the Vikram Seths of the world to write about the UK or the US).
Mayank Tewari seems to be all those things, and ignorant besides. He doesn't even know that "Scoop Wallah" was a bestseller in 1999 in both the UK and India and that this is a republication. I doubt he read the book properly either as the reason it was a bestseller in India at the time is because it does NOT contain the usual cliches. (There's only one cow, and it's mentioned briefly because it's responsible for the author missing a deadline).
Sunday, October 18, 2009 15:57 IST
S. Rojack, London
This book has not "been published now after, after a decade" - it's a reissue of a book that was a bestseller in the mid-nineties! I read and enjoyed it ten years ago when it was first released.... The other day I picked up this new edition where it clearly states in the author's introduction that the book was first published in 1999. I find it alarming that your reviewer just skims a book to the extent that such basic information is missed. It also means he doesn't get that this isn't a book that jumps on the foreigner in modern India bandwagon; it is the book that started it.
Sunday, October 18, 2009 15:44 IST
Sarabjit Singh, Delhi
Getting jiggy with it
Almost everyone wore white for designer Hemant Trivedi's birthday party and that included Aishwarya Rai Bachchan who made a special appearance for her old friend and guru.
The week that was: November 15 - November 21, 2009
Here are the top national and international stories from the past week

Get daily news in your inbox and read it at your convenience.

D