Home > India > Report

Gay is bad, chorus maulanas, saffron brigade & Church

Deepak Gidwani & Puneet Nicholas Yadav / DNA
Thursday, July 2, 2009 18:15 IST
Email Email
Print Print
Share Share

Lucknow/ Delhi: Religious leaders are not pleased with the Delhi high court order. Interestingly, this is one rare issue maulanas, saffron brigade and the Church seem to agree on.


Related videos
Complete Coverage

Lucknow's Naib Imam and a member of the All-India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) Maulana Khalid Rashid Firangi Mahali quoted Soorate Houd, verse number 88 of the Quran, to say those who practised homosexuality in times of Hazrat Houd became victims of divine wrath.

Bajrang Dal's national convener Prakash Sharma said: "The judgment is unfortunate... this is a Congress conspiracy... it seems some top Congress leaders are gay."

"Homosexuality is an offence under Islam and there are very few nations that have legalised it," the Maulana elaborated. He termed it unnatural, ungodly and against Indian culture and moral values. "Sanctioning it should not be tolerated. Legalising homosexuality would lead to an increase in sex-related crimes, especially sodomy, where children would be victims," he said.

"The Centre is giving undue attention to this non-issue... there are so many other important things which deserve the government's attention," the Maulana said.

Sharma said: "We will fight this (court order). We will go to the Supreme Court, even take to the streets, if need be.

"The government should bring an ordinance to ban homosexuality... on one hand, we are spending crores on AIDS prevention ads and on the other, we legalise gay sex."

Mufti Mohammad Abdul Khalik Madarsi, deputy vice-chancellor of Dar-ul-Uloom (Deoband) is alarmed at the "contemptible move likely to corrupt the gullible in society". He warned the government "not to pander to the wishes of the sinful few".

Mufti Mohammad Arshad Farooqui of the fatwa department of Dar-ul-Uloom said, "A joint forum of Hindus, Muslim and Christians should be set up to check legalisation of homosexuality. In a country with five million HIV-affected, sanctioning homosexuality in the name of radical thinking would be like committing suicide. Even medical science has proved its harmful impact on human civilisation."

Maulana Naimuddin, secretary, Islamic Centre of India, said Islam allowed physical relationship between man and woman only. "Rest of the gair fitri (unnatural) bonds are strictly prohibited."
"This verdict will spoil the future generations," Kamal Farooqi, another AIMPLBmember said.

"Homosexuality is not an acceptable behaviour. This can't be treated as a matter of legality alone, it's highly immoral," Father Babu Joseph, spokesperson for the Catholic Bishop's Conference of India, said.

Yoga Guru Baba Ramdev said, "The verdict will encourage criminality and sick mentality. This kind of thing is shameful and insulting. We are blindly following the West in everything. This is breaking the family system in India. Homosexuals are sick people, they should be sent to hospitals for treatment. If the government brings this law, I will take to the streets of Delhi in protest."

The Shahi Imam of Delhi's Jama Masjid, Ahmed Bukhari, said, "This is such a dirty issue. I have decided I will not even speak about it because if I do, it will be an insult to our belief and me. The government cannot dare to make this legal."

Copyright permission mandatory to republish this article.
For reprint rights click here
digg reddit google Facebook MySpace delicious

Post your comment

Readers' comments:
Ooh, mullahs and swamijis hand in hand... Ishwar Allah tero naam indeed.
Monday, August 10, 2009 21:17 IST
somegal, someplace
As a student of yoga and a teacher and practitioner of its sister science, ayurveda, I am hesitant to level criticism at anyone, much less pass judgement on another.

In this instance, I must make an exception.

Swami Ramdev's actions have nothing to do with yoga or healing, nor with the Sanatana Dharma (eternal truth). His attempts to bring the sanctions of criminal law against the life choices of others categorize him as an enemy of freedom and truth, willing for the sake of egotism to sacrifice the happiness and well being of millions on the altar of the god of self-aggrandizement.

Some notion of the swami's concept of and commitment to promoting health might be had from his fraudulent claims of curing AIDS, cancer, and -- most egregiously -- his promotion of a purported ayurvedic "medicine" labelled Putravati, supposed to help women to selectively give birth to sons.

Swamiji's efforts to promote the marginalization of homosexuality and the dispossession of gay and lesbian people of their human rights may well win applause in the homophobic, misogynistic backwaters of the subcontinent's countless villages. His condemnation of the peaceful methods of Mohandas Gandhi and the utility of non-violence in gaining India's independence bloodlessly may play well to the right-wing rump of Indian reactionary politics. But he has revealed himself to a much wider world to be a charlatan and a poseur.

This is no man of God, and his reprehensible conduct is a disgrace to the sanyasin's robe. His conduct has been condemned by his own teacher.
Sunday, July 12, 2009 21:06 IST
William Courson, Montclair, New Jersey, USA
Shame on India. Shame on Indian courts. Shame on the religions that teach this principle and give rise to such sick people. We are proud to be Muslims, such a tidy, neat, and clean religion. Islam teaches us to respect humanity and sacred relations. Social animals will become real animals just for the sake and thirst of sex.
Friday, July 3, 2009 12:39 IST
ahmad ali, rawalpindi
Have heterosexuals THE WORLD OVER lost their collective MINDS? You all REALLY think that THE VERY HOMOSEXUALS THAT HETEROSEXUALS THEMSELVES CREATED would just take abuse after abuse after abuse from you? Really? Did you never stop and think that there just MIGHT come a day when we stood and said NO MORE ABUSE FROM OUR CREATORS?

Morals indeed, heteros. Morals, indeed.
Friday, July 3, 2009 2:31 IST
Bill, New York
One of a kind
A lavish bash was organised for the first anniversary celebrations of the plush suburban hotel, Intercontinental, The Lalit.
Minds that conquered MIT
A group of students from Bangalore bagged the award for the best presentation at the sixth International Genetically Engineered Machine competition.

Get daily news in your inbox and read it at your convenience.

D