Home > India > Report

If taking dowry is a crime, so is giving, says court

Vineeta Pandey
Friday, December 5, 2008 3:31 IST
Email Email
Print Print
Share Share

Noida magistrate orders action against bride's family for giving dowry and misusing Act to settle personal scores

NEW DELHI: A Noida court has ordered police to book a woman and her parents for giving dowry. The chief judicial magistrate (CJM) of Noida ordered the police to register an FIR against Noida-based call centre employee Natasha Juyal and her parents under section 3 of the Dowry Prohibition Act (DPA) for giving dowry. The CJM also ordered action against police officers who refused to register Natasha's husband Namit Juyal's complaint.

Giving or taking dowry is a criminal offence under Section 3 of the DPA with imprisonment. This is a rare case where the section was evoked against a woman and her family.

Namit's lawyer Pradeep Nawani argued that Natasha had not only accepted to giving dowry, but also submitted a list of stridhan that was not as per the DPA. Even her claim of huge wedding expense did not match her father's financial capacity.

According to Nawani, Natasha filed a complaint of dowry harassment in Noida's sector-20 police station last year, saying Namit was given Rs10 lakh as dowry in 2005.

The Noida police arrested Namit and packed him off to Dasna jail in UP. After getting bail, Namit sought information under RTI from the Noida police, seeking to know on what basis he was arrested.

He was horrified to hear that he was arrested on the basis of his wife's mere written complaint and verbal statement with no records to back her allegations. He then asked police to register a complaint against his wife and family for giving dowry.

On refusal by the police, he approached court to get a complaint registered against his wife and her parents. He also sought contempt of court action against the police for failing to comply with a supreme court order, stipulating that refusing to register police complaint by a husband in a dowry case is tantamount to the contempt of court.

p_vineeta@dnaindia.net

digg reddit google Facebook MySpace delicious

Post your comment

Readers' comments:
Why would dowry be a crime when alimony is not a crime? Is the money given by women a crime and not vice versa? Any answers?
Sunday, October 25, 2009 7:03 IST
raj, chennai
This makes total sense. I am glad to see that India is putting an unbiased attitude towards women in this day and age. Husbands who are unnecessarily blackmailed or harassed should fight back only if not guilty, and put the weight on the tormenting and greedy wives. The police at least now cannot refuse to lodge an FIR after such a ruling by the hon'ble judge.
Tuesday, June 9, 2009 12:38 IST
raj kanwar, Bombay
I understand that the bias of the anti-dowry act stays with women. and it is also good to know that some people are now taking it to an impressive level to fight it. But most of us don't know that it is a lost battle already. I mean how many people really know the levels of corruption in the Indian court rooms which stink. Take your life to fight injustice in the dowry courts and they will take your lives out. If you loose, you are dead forever. If you win, you get an apology from the courts which you will never en cash. Ask this guy, namit as to how he feels after going to that shitty dasna jail. I feel that he has already lost the battle. The system has defeated him by putting him behind bars.
Regards
Wednesday, February 25, 2009 17:24 IST
Vivek Verma
That's great news. This should enlighten the law makers, and make the innocent victims raise their voice against the injustice meted out to them due to a law which seems heavily biased.
Wednesday, December 10, 2008 10:37 IST
arjun
I congratulate Namit for fighting the misuse of the act against taking dowry. It is unfortunate that he was arrested without any proof of wrong doing by him.
Sunday, December 7, 2008 16:38 IST
Ramawtar Sharma
More comments »
Mumbai mindset
Ritam Banerjee exhibited his perception of Mumbai city during the opening of his photography exhibition Mumbai: The City That Talks to Me.
Minds that conquered MIT
A group of students from Bangalore bagged the award for the best presentation at the sixth International Genetically Engineered Machine competition.

Get daily news in your inbox and read it at your convenience.

D