India
There’s a notion, quite popular on Whatsapp and other forms of social media, which believes that Hindu festivals are unfairly targeted by elitists.
Updated : Mar 02, 2018, 06:57 PM IST
There’s a notion, quite popular on Whatsapp and other forms of social media, which believes that Hindu festivals are unfairly targeted by elitists and 'liberals'.
It’s as if the electrons of outrage are activated every time a Hindu festival nears which are painted as symbolic of the ills that plague society.
Diwali is the season to moan about air and noise pollution, Karva Chauth and Rakhi are celebration of unending patriarchy, whilst Holi is the time to remember water pollution.
Of course, there’s no denying that vulgar individuals use Holi as a mask to unleash their inner pervert but in general, the school of thought that popular Hindu festivals are mocked by the manor-born refuses to go away.
On Friday, India’s biggest selling English author, Chetan Bhagat weighed in with his words of wisdom.
While some feel that it’s a general disregard for Hinduism by ‘elitists’, Bhagat felt that it wasn’t so much about the religion as ‘elitists looking down upon the masses’.
He wrote on Twitter: “It's not so much Hinduism. Elitists in India just love looking down on whatever the masses do: how they celebrate Holi, how they celebrate Diwali, Hindi, Bollywood, Indian Television, their political choices. It's how they try to stay elite. Ignore them.”
As usual, Bhagat’s comments set off the lions with scores agreeing with him on Twitter with others pointing out that it wasn’t elitism to speak about consent. The debate followed the uproar after allegations that semen-filled balloons were hurled at girls in Delhi.
Here are some of the tweets that followed:
It's not so much Hinduism. Elitists in India just love looking down on whatever the masses do: how they celebrate Holi, how they celebrate Diwali, Hindi, Bollywood, Indian Television, their political choices. It's how they try to stay elite. Ignore them.
— Chetan Bhagat (@chetan_bhagat) March 2, 2018
Indian television is mostly garbage. Also, hindi? Seriously? https://t.co/FMog7ccwY6
— killmonger's fan (@Winkerbell_) March 2, 2018
He is basically asking u to read his books https://t.co/fbKCd6PhX5
— ABHISHEK BID (@AbhishekBid) March 2, 2018
I have to agree with him here. https://t.co/6UBTslKqgi
— Ankur (@ankurjainiam) March 2, 2018
There is a need to delete this elite.
— Swami Kumar Maharaj (@swanikmaharaj) March 2, 2018
Who gave them the title of elite?
Their ideas & attitudes don't matter a jot to 99.9999% of Indians. https://t.co/X7woHuBGX6
Why would somebody have a problem with spreading cheer & joy? The only problem people have with Holi is the rampant sexual harassment.
— Jas Oberoi (@iJasOberoi) March 2, 2018
Shouldn’t people look down upon that? Should it be accepted just because masses do it? Are you so lame & stupid @chetan_bhagat? https://t.co/5gQQgr4b42
Exactly dear @chetan_bhagat .this is why post 2014 these elements r irritated as they feel that power is now with real bharat ke log. https://t.co/Z9QSswDKs5
— Dr kumar Rahul (@drrahulsaksham) March 2, 2018
What he does not realize is that Hindi is itself the languages of the elite in the North who frequent look down upon the speakers of other languages like Awadhi, Braj and Bhojpuri as 'Dehati'. In the hierarchy of elites, Hindi speakers are only a notch below the anglophone elite https://t.co/Ji7csah685
— Ayush Khanna (@AyushyaKhanna) March 2, 2018
Elitists have caused immense loss to nation by keeping the larger section of public excluded from development ; thereby extremely poor ...
— Dilip Gandhi (@surewrap) March 2, 2018
Now the time and tide is turning against them... in no time they will be swept off .. as the larger section is being empowered ... https://t.co/TDXZxDvdOX
True at larger extent @chetan_bhagat https://t.co/rsr87GNtzP
— Shivam Kumar Rai (@raishivam1012) March 2, 2018
OK so I shouldn't look down upon how someone's forcefully putting colors on me (read molesting), or polluting air to a level where I can't breathe?
— Shruti (@Physio_Shruti) March 2, 2018
Understood sir! Thanks for the enlightenment. https://t.co/e5zKWN4CqJ
Of course, makes sense. Masses read Chetan Bhagat books. https://t.co/g1kYNJf2Cj
— Solivagant Flâneur (@kcunal) March 2, 2018
Of course, makes sense. Masses read Chetan Bhagat books. https://t.co/g1kYNJf2Cj
— Solivagant Flâneur (@kcunal) March 2, 2018
Once in a while, I do agree with you.
— Sadhavi Khosla (@sadhavi) March 2, 2018
The debate about Holi is far from over, and will probably be rehashed next year also. Similarly, the larger point of whether Hindu festivals are being targetted by a section of the elites have no easy answer. Some would say, it is merely an effort to fill the lacunae present in the religion.
But in all that, Chetan Bhagat's reputation as the agent provocateur remains untarnished. Many believe he merely panders to majoritarian feelings, and tries to play the role of the underdog, not acknowledging his position of privilege. But Bhagat again managed to polarise opinion on Twitter, ignite a conversation, which probably was his intention from the beginning.