Cricket
During a domestic limited-overs tournament in Australia, Labuschagne became the first victim of ICC's latest rule against 'fake fielding'. Twitterverse, though, isn't happy with yet another law that blatantly favours a batsman.
Updated : Sep 30, 2017, 10:50 AM IST
International Cricket Council's (ICC) latest rule against 'fake fielding' came into play recently. The rule states that a fielder cannot pretend to throw the ball and deceive a batsman when they don't actually have the ball in their hand.
According to the MCC's new Law 41.5: "It is unfair for any fielder willfully to attempt, by word or action, to distract, deceive or obstruct either batsman after the striker has received the ball."
The first victim to this latest regulation was Queensland Bulls fielder Marnus Labuschagne. The incident happened during a JLT One-Day Cup (domestic limited-overs tournament of Australia) match between Queensland Bulls and Cricket Australia XI. Labuschagne dived and tried to stop a cover-drive hit by Cricket Australia XI batsman Param Uppal, but failed to get a hand on the ball. He then tried to trick the batsman by faking a throw.
The on-field umpires noticed what Labuschagne tried to pull off and decided to hand a five-run penalty to Queensland Bulls.
The question that arises, though, is that does cricket need another rule that blatantly favours a batsman? What's the harm in 'fake fielding' anyway? Going by this logic, should football referees start handing out Yellow Cards when a players does a Step-Over? Because in a Step-Over, a player tries to deceive the opponent by faking his movement towards one direction and then going the other way. A five-run penalty for a harmless act such as 'fake fielding' seems rather harsh.
This sentiment against punishment for 'fake 'fielding' was echoed by many on Twitter.
Marnus Labuschagne breaks cricket's new fake fielding rule, costs Queensland Bulls 5 penalty runs.
— Mohandas Menon (@mohanstatsman) September 30, 2017
But is it fair?https://t.co/GlBs0m8m0t
Another Law favouring the batsman. Totally unfair!
— Mohandas Menon (@mohanstatsman) September 30, 2017
I saw the video. This rule is ridiculous.
— Rutvij (@rutvij76) September 30, 2017
Next thing - A rule that bowler can not bowl Dusara because it deceives the batsman!!
With so many rules in place the day is not far when cricket will be played by 22 programmed robots.
— RÖY (@19AJR) September 30, 2017
if it was done in baseball they'd call it trick play,just takes out the element of surprise or doubt,buries Innovation,Unfair
— VadaPav Intellectual (@ShantanuVa) September 30, 2017
ridiculous rule. To make it even they should fine batsmen if they change their shot at the last moment. Lol!
— Prathamesh Shende (@Pratz2106) September 30, 2017
What nonsense... totally unfair.
— Suresh Kumar (@sureshkrd) September 30, 2017
Imagine you apply this rule in soccer.. No dribbling ! :)
So batsman batsman should be penalised for his mishits too for his fake batting
— Ejaj Shaikh (@ejajshkh) September 30, 2017
Stupid rule... The whole game has become batsman friendly.
— Kappi decoction (@KappiDecoction) September 30, 2017