Follow us:              
You are here: HOME > BLOGS >

Sitting (Bombay) ducks?

| Friday, November 28, 2008

Having lived through the 1993 blasts more closely than most since I was trapped in my car when the bomb at Plaza cinema had gone off, I thought that life’s worst nightmare was over. But even that horrific event does not compare with what has transpired over the past two days. This really is hellish.

The 1993 blasts were perhaps more sinister for the sheer number of casualties, but this one is clearly the more diabolical. Back then, in some ways, it seemed like a `cause and effect’ syndrome, and that revenge was the motive. Now, however, what cause except to kill and cause mayhem?

Article continues below the advertisement...

Fifteen years ago, we were in many ways still `innocent’ about terrorism. We had had several communal riots before and since Partition, and obviously the demolition of the Babri Masjid had scarred an entire community living in the country. Yet, till the investigations began in that case, it seemed impossible that `bomb blasts’ were even possible.

But since then, we have lived through several such incidents around the country and the world – with 9/11 obviously a catharsis point in modern history -- so how come we still know so little about how these things happen, or how to prevent them?

At this point in time, I find no solace in the optimistic outpourings that have deluged us since the horrific terror attack began more than 24 hours ago. Let’s not talk about the famed spirit of Mumbai which has helped us take us take severe setbacks in our stride. This just does not cut ice any more.

It's not that the `Mumbai spirit' has vanished, but it is certainly under duress. The people of this city are scared, angry and bitter like never earlier. I reckon the fear will recede as people get back to their daily lives, but the anger and bitterness will linger much longer. This became evident to me at the marriage reception in Colaba on Wednesday evening when the siege began, and in office all of Thursday speaking to colleagues, answering calls from friends and strangers.

The apprehension in everyone is transparent, as is the seething anger at being reduced to such hapless victims. There are several queries thathave reverberated in my years from speaking to various people, of which I have listed the most frequently recurring.

1) How could terrorists sneak into this city into boats without any intelligence agency having a whiff of what's happening?

2) How come when something like this happens, the leaders who otherwise make the most noise, try to grab the most headlines, seek to create differences between people within the country itself, are never to be found?

3) If the Prime Minister and the government insist that there are extreme elements envious of the country's progress and always likely to indulge in acts of terror, why were no major steps taken to counter this?

4) How come the opposition leaders, led by Mr L K Advani, suddenly start singingpraises of the Anti Terrorist Squad and its head Hemant Karakare when till just the other day, they were maligning both for pursuing the Sadhvi and Purohit cases?

I know it is easy to hammer politicians, police and authority, but I suspect these questions are symptomatic of the `fed-upness' of the people with those who they believe seek to run their lives. The overriding sentiment seems to be: Enough is enough.

From this despair, however, could emerge the national strength and will to fight this menace collectively. The key action points to combat terrorism: are: Strong political will, uncompromising law and order mechanism, fine-tuned intelligence network, and a citizenry that is not divided within itself, whatever the provocations.

The last mentioned, in many ways, is perhaps the most crucial because it creates the platform for how the other action points will deliver. The onus is on us.

Copyright permission mandatory to republish this article. For reprint rights click here
More posts by :
Comments  |  Post a comment
By Kiran
Dec 11, 2008
Only answer for all these questions is that we need to have a seperate institution to look after all the strategic and tactical defence needs of our country. Irony is that all our military affairs are look after by civilan leadership, which has no knowledge and idea of strength, only respects strength. Our political leaders are similar to Chacha Nehru who was under the impression that Indian security forces are invincible as exhibited in our history and stories. They need to wake up and look seriously towards modernisation of our security forces.
By vibhu
Dec 2, 2008
Wud like 2 add 1 more point....
What abt d gr8 rr patil who makes a comment like''such small things keep happening in big cities''.....what does he mean by dis stupid statement?Wud it have been a big thing 4 him if 5000 people had died.Thank god he is finally thrown out....such people have no right 2 be in charge of our country's security as dey take more fancy in their gabbana suits and frequent China trips which is btw funded from the tax we pay...
By Eklavya
Nov 30, 2008
The carnage witnessed live on TV world over and the erudite and expressive analyzes that have followed from Defense Experts, Journalists of note, Social Icons and the dirty adjectival Politician have raised several questions including the ones that Ayaz has listed in his post.

However, what crosses my mind at this point in time is :

Who does this country belong to?

I have been trying to reach a well reasoned answer to this question for several years and perhaps decades as I believe that this question of ownership if answered correctly would bring in the attendant responsibility of its safekeeping. Yet every honest attempt to include the Experts, the Journalists, the Politicians, the Social Icon and the Business Leader as the coterie of people to whom this country belongs leaves me with the dissatisfaction of having excluded the survivors of the people who died in action against the madness that has been encouraged over the decades. I am dissatisfied at the exclusion of the unsuspecting hawker on the Road who invariably is deprived of his daily livelihood on every such recurrence of madness. I am sad at the desolate and vacant eyes of the child who is deprived of the only full meal at school because the schools are shut down as a measure of precaution every time the masters of the borders ( aerial/land/marine) meticulously overlook all signals of an impending attack and its underlying preparations.

An archaic voting system, politically controlled security system and repeated terror attack almost at a religious interval are all symptoms and not the disease itself. We must get to the disease and treat the same. The diagnosis of the disease would need a group of minds that have the freedom to think and have the freedom to administer medicine or undertake surgery as the disease warrants. Then we need to give the nation time to convalesce. Who would these men be? Would they be the people who have managed to attain eminence as a result of their suave handling of the extant bureaucracy and political leadership. Undoubtedly, the men of eminence may be having the skill to negotiate with the dirtiest self-centered people at the helm of affairs but they may not necessarily have the competence to think with an open mind and take unselfish actions for the benefit of the Society. The need is to revert to the Philosopher King and his courtiers who would dispense justice and not any sugar coated commodities of temporal taste.
By N Chandra Shekar
Nov 28, 2008
Manmohans address to the Nation:

I strongly condemn...

I offer my deepest condolences...

I salute the courage and patriotism...

I assure the country that we will attend in an urgent and serious manner...

We will take the strongest possible measures...

We will take up strongly with our neighbours...

We will take a number of measures to strengthen the hands of our police...

We will go after these individuals and organisations...

In this hour of tragedy, I appeal to the people to maintain peace and harmony...

We will go after these individuals and organisations and make sure that every perpetrator, organiser and supporter of terror... pays a heavy price for these cowardly and horrific acts against our people

Ha Ha Ha...

Ha Ha Ha...

Ha Ha Ha...

God Save our Souls!!!
says:

Reactions here to the post are symptomatic of the sentiment, not just in Mumbai, but across the nation. The collective will of the people is impossible to ignore, and the spate of resignations -- at the centre and state -- suggests hopefully some accountability is settling in.

By Sharma.KayYes
Nov 28, 2008
I read somewhere earlier that terrorists are likely to use sea route but our politicians are busy in arguing about Hindu or Muslim terrorism. The leaders do not care for defence services as they depend on Babus in their day to day activities. But now who are sacrificing their lives where our leaders and Babus cannot even dare to come nearby to such action areas? We should elect only the educated and technical savvy people and eliminate all these advanis and patels and thackerays. Let us amend the constitution to introduce qualifications and age limits to the contestants to public offices. God save India.
By Sapphire
Nov 28, 2008
I agree with you,,,but instead of waiting for these politicians/police etc wait to make a plan to save us...do u think we as v v v hurt and angry citizens make a plan for our selves to protect us from these ppl
Some questions to ask

1. why do v pay so much tax? is it being used? should v stop paying it?
2. Who are the ppl we vote for? what are their credentials?
3. Should politicians should be banned from visiting accident sites incl hospitals to solicit votes

We are not a growing country, not even third world...at this rate!
India is NOT SHINING!!
By siddhu
Nov 28, 2008
excellent article

a special mention needs to be made of the absolute fools who came to watch what they thought was a 'tamasha' at the Taj yesterday...they seriously threatened the security arrangements in place
  


Popular blogs
Most...
©2012 Diligent Media Corporation Ltd.
D.0