Follow us:              
You are here: HOME > BLOGS > ANIRUDDHA GUHA

Aniruddha Guha

Review: Kabhi khushi, kabhi Singham

Aniruddha Guha | Friday, July 22, 2011

Film: Singham
Director: Rohit Shetty
Cast
: Ajay Devgn, Kajal Aggarwal, Prakash Raj and others
Rating: ***

Article continues below the advertisement...

I haven't watched the original Singham (Singam, in Tamil), but a promo on YouTube made it seem like a film that is loud, kitsch-filled and full of dialoguebaazi. That was what I was expecting from the Hindi Singham too. It was what I got. I wasn't disappointed.

Singham's story is as obvious as it can get. There's a good cop (fearless, upright, conscientious, can bash up to 20 goons at once etc). Pitted against him is an evil politician (he kills, steals, indulges in corruption etc).

The plot unfolds somewhat like this: Cop is introduced as Dabangg, oops, Singham (clap trap 1), he rubs politician the wrong way, politician makes life hell for cop, cop meets girl (who girl?), cop gets back at politician (clap trap 2), cop sings songs with girl (who girl?), politician gets back at cop, cop gets back at politician (clap trap 3), one final clash, cop wins (final round of seeti taali). Cop finally walks in sunset with girl (who girl, dammit!).

The Tamil version aside, there were at least three Hindi films that Singham distinctly reminded me of. The first was Mahesh Manjrekar's Kurukshetra, where Sanjay Dutt played an honest officer posted in a police station where most of his subordinates are corrupt. The second was Singham hero Ajay Devgn's earlier film, Gangaajal, directed by Prakash Jha, where a group of hapless cops, tired of having their hands tied down by the corrupt system, take a drastic step.

The third, and the most obvious inspiration for Singham, came from the Rajkumar Santoshi-directed Khakee. In fact, an entire scene in Khakee and much of the monologue delivered by Amitabh Bachchan to a corrupt cop - "agar policewaala chahe toh saala koi bache ke haath se ek khilona nahi chura sake" - is repeated, "bache ke haath se khilona" replaced with "mandir ke bahaar se ek chappal", followed by "yahaan toh system hi hamaari thokne main laga hua hai," the dialogue identical to the one in Khakee.

Singham, therefore, has almost nothing you haven't already watched before. There's also a love track thrown in which is in no way connected to the main story. Kajal Aggarwal doesn't mind debuting in a film where all she has to do is look cute and help the hero show his "soft side". She works given the framework. All the songs do, in the words of a trade analyst, is provide audiences with "loo breaks" every now and then.

So should you watch Singham then? Probably. A throwback to the kind of films you regularly witnessed in the '80s and '90s, Singham manages to pull all the right strings you expect from an escapist fare. Director Rohit Shetty goes all the way, some maudlin dialogues (by Farhad-Sajid) making you cringe, many others you enjoy thanks mainly to good actors.

In Prakash Raj, you get to see one of the best Hindi film villains in recent times. Known for his performances in south Indian films (he won a National award for Kanchivaram a couple of years ago), Raj fills the gap of the antagonist left by the likes of Amrish Puri and Prem Chopra. He also brings his own distinct touch of humour to his villainy.

Devgn is at home in a role that he can probably sleepwalk through. He lets himself go this time, having a blast playing the 'big-muscaled' social crusader. He struggles to get his Maharashtrian accent right, though, throwing in phrases like 'tujha aaicha' and 'cha maila' every now and then to make it seem authentic.

Shetty intelligently casts a number of Maharashtrian actors (Vijay Patkar, Anant Jog, Sonali Kulkarni, Sachin Khedekar, Govind Namdeo), a requirement given the story set in a small town on the Maharashtra-Goa border. An extended cameo by Ashok Saraf as a head constable on the verge of retirement is among the film's highlights.

Sadly, though, for a film banking so heavily on its action sequences, the choreography by Shetty doesn't go beyond flying cars and far-flung men. He shuns stylised action for the kind of maardhaad you saw in action films of yore, which jars. As director, he accomplishes what he aims for - playing to the gallery unabashedly.

Singham is kitsch at its best. If the idea of a bunch of cops kicking a politician on his backside till it gets sore amuses you, go for it. I particularly enjoyed that sequence.

Copyright permission mandatory to republish this article. For reprint rights click here
Comments  |  Post a comment
By Ashish Ray
Sep 3, 2011
Kya re Choti wale baba...tera review sab blog par nahi aa rela hai...main that girl in yellow boots ka tera review padha...tere ko ekdum picture samajh nahi aaya ...aisa bhi tera cinema ka understanding weak hai....tu khaali salman khan ka film ka review kar...baaki tere bas ka nahi hai...
By Yeleswaram Mamatha
Jul 28, 2011
Its Really fantastic to know About all the Things Happening in the Film industry.
By kesava
Jul 28, 2011
Guys,

Dont under estimate tamil movie industry. As like all other industries, it also has some crap movies coming jus for entertainment. Its sad that these days only those kind of movies are remade in Hindi. There are lots of soleful and even at times good intellectual movies comes out in Tamil. Evidence is a spate of awards it recently got in National awards this year, including best film and best story
Aniruddha Guha says:

You are bang on Kesava, but most producers remake films that have done well at the box office - it gives them a ready concept to begin with, and the fact that it's done well probably increases their confidence in the story. Having said that, I agree that watching remakes of good films (like Aadukalam, that won the National award for Best Director), and not necessarily 'hit' films, would be refreshing. But is any producer listening? (or reading, in this case).

By ashish ray
Jul 27, 2011
Kya choti killer tu to senti ho gaya re...kya girl friend tough time de reli hai kya...ya bhag gayi tere best friend ke saath...boli tumhare baal mere baal se lambe kaise?....
Aniruddha Guha says:

Kya Ashish. Film ki story likh raha hai kya?

By manish
Jul 27, 2011
Dear Anirudh, Even by your logic, he is not maharashtrian by any way!! His forefathers had no roots in Maharashtra. They never migrated from Maharashtra. Namdeos are native of Western Bundelkhand region of Madhya Prdesh, major town is Sagar. They speak Bundelkhandi (a language used in Pipli Live). Even marathi is not their mother tongue!!
He never acted in Marathi theatre or fims. Just because now he lives in Maharashtra or his surname resembles with marathi surname, you cannot say he is a marathi actor...
I was just correcting your fact. By that logic Ashutosh Rana should be a Rajsthani
because his surname resembles with Ranas & maharanas of Rajsthani Rajput community?!!
Aniruddha Guha says:

Dear Manish, I checked with a filmmaker who had worked with Govind Namdeo after having received the earlier comment, and replied only after he told me that Namdeo was indeed Maharashtrian. But you seem to have a greater knowledge of his roots and are probably right. Thanks for pointing out.

By clem
Jul 27, 2011
You're totally right !!! In fact I gave only two stars to this film but your critic is perfect "singham is kitsch at its best" ahah that's so right !!
Aniruddha Guha says:

Glad you think so, Clem.

By Sunny Solomon
Jul 27, 2011
In MahaKalyuga, a human being's mind goes inward ( in a very negative sense, I mean), becomes clogged with wayward thoughts and unsuitable actions as watching this boring and dull movie. Even duller than this flick is ZMHD or whatever. Watching Katrina is embarrassing and Hritik's crab-hand is a big distraction and a major puke-inducer. But then this is Kal Yuga....so everything goes...
Aniruddha Guha says:

I'd like to know a movie you watched recently that you didn't think was dull. Thanks.

By Naina
Jul 26, 2011
I like your views.......realistic .To be a mature audience we have to develop our taste and try to watch movie holistically and not from its fixed standards. Otherwise we will never get better . To enjoy one should appreciate and to learn one should critise ...
Aniruddha Guha says:

Interesting take, Naina. Thanks for sharing.

By Yogesh
Jul 26, 2011
Bakwas review at all.
Film got 5 out of 5 star!
Aniruddha Guha says:

Ok Yogesh. I now give it 6 out of 5 star!

By ashish ray
Jul 26, 2011
kya film critic...khud se acha acha comment likh kar daal rela hai kya?...honest review etc..ya dost log ko bol raha hai...aur govind namdeo marathi kab se ho gaya?...aila...tere ko itna saal ho gaya hai mumbai main rehte rehte..aur abhi bhi ye nai jaanta kaun marathi manoos hai kaun nahi hai...tere ghar ke saamne main protestor log ko bhejega...Choti killer hai hai...jai maharashtra..
Aniruddha Guha says:

dekha. phir aa gaya na tu. ekdum phukatchand hai tu. aur kya doosre log ka comment khud ke naam pe chipkaarela hai. khud ka soch ke aa na. namdeo maharashtrian hai yaan nahi uska reply main neeche de chuka hai. chal abhi bye.

By Asish
Jul 26, 2011
Was a really entertaining,comic and refreshing movie different from usual hero-heroine bollywood film with bulshit romance. Dont know why people in North have such pre concieved notions like south indian movies are illogical. Those who say surely havent watched south indian movies.

Honest review.
By Mohit
Jul 26, 2011
Our entertainment industry has the habit of following hit trends blindly. I am just worried about how just after one hit in Wanted, every other film coming now is a south indian movie remake and has the some physics defying stunts which i thought north indian public had always hated. Seems like i was wrong, but as if south indian cinema was not enough now bollywood is also turning into sexist-illogical larger than life drama. I really hate such kind of cinema.
By Vivekanand
Jul 26, 2011
Dear Aniruddha Guha,

I must embrace you for this review. Given the high-tension aura encircling our actors, it is commendable to be so precise and honest. And you made it.

Thanks.
V
Aniruddha Guha says:

Thanks V.

By manish
Jul 25, 2011
Dear film critic, Govind Namdeo is not Maharashtrian!! He is a NSD paas out and was a NDS faculty before joining films. He belongs to Sagar (Madhya Pradesh).
Aniruddha Guha says:

Dear Manish, by that logic every Punjabi in Maharashtra is a Maharashtrian and every Bengali in Gujarat is a Gujarati.

By Ashish Ray
Jul 25, 2011
kya choti killer...tere ko koi comment nahi kar raha hai...tera abhi likhne ka style ekdum essay maafik hai...reader ko film review mangta hai...essay nahi...essay likhne ka hai to Mumbai university phir se join kar...tere ko bahut number denge udhar..first division main pass ho jayega tu...idhar khaali peeli reader log ka time khoti kao ke karta hai...chal jai maharashtra..
Aniruddha Guha says:

ashish ray, ab tu paka rela hai. har post pe bas ekich maafik comment chhod rela hai. thhoda innovative ho na.


aur waise, tera time khoti hai aisa hi lagta hai. comment chhod ne ke ilaava kuch karta hai tu, aisa lagta toh nahi hai mujhko.

By suvro
Jul 25, 2011
Nice review.
Aniruddha Guha says:

Thanks Suvro.

By subash
Jul 24, 2011
The movie is good but I never liked it.
Aniruddha Guha says:

You don't like good movies, Subash?

  


Popular blogs
Most...
©2012 Diligent Media Corporation Ltd.
D.0